• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Who's got the best November Auction?

Started by Hedge Collector,

49 posts in this topic

TheWatcher

TheWatcher

Posted
Posted

Heritage has the edge in GA & OA, CLink has the edge in SA (I don't follow BA/CA/Modern so I didn't figure them into the equation). I'm watching HA,Clink and Qualitycomix because they all have books I'm interested in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Hedge Collector

Hedge Collector

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I think it depends on what you collect. If Golden Age is your thing, then Heritage is the clear winner in November.

 

No doubt. Not to mention OA.

 

I also think ComicLinks SA selection is great (again), but Heritage seems to have enough SA material that overall it puts their total auction selection ahead of ComicLinks for me.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
kimik

kimik

Posted
Posted
Everyone's got a November Auction it seems. Who's the best?

 

Is it - Heritage > ComicLink > Pedigree > ComicConnect > QualityComix?

 

Where would the Mound City Auction have ranked?

 

I would still place Mound City above Clink for SA books based on the quality and depth of selection for both Marvel and DC. The Clink auction has more copies of key issues available, but Mound City still beat them grade wise on a lot of the big ones (AF #15 8.0, X-Men #1 9.4, Avengers #1 9.4, SC #22 8.0) and had nice HG runs of most SA titles.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
buttock

buttock

Posted
Posted

comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Hedge Collector

Hedge Collector

Posted
  • Author
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

What has Zurzolo been doing? Maybe he is about to unleash the mother of all collections next week?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
metropoliscomics

metropoliscomics

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

ACTION COMICS-1938 -----------------------------------------------------

2 FN-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. of Superman)

 

ADVENTURE COMICS 1938-83 -----------------------------------------------

40 FN+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Sandman)

 

ALL AMERICAN COMICS ----------------------------------------------------

16 VG+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Green Lantern classic Shelly-c)

 

ALL STAR COMICS --------------------------------------------------------

3 FN

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Justice Society of America, classic cover)

 

BATMAN -----------------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Joker/1st Catwoman)

2 F/VF

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. Joker/2nd Catwoman Kane & Robinson-c/a)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

30 VG-

(CGC off white pgs 4 pc tape ic; Guardineer-c)

31 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs Slight(P); classic Batman over castle cover 1st Batplane.)

35 VG-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; Classic Hypo/Bondage cover)

38 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Extensive (P); Origin & 1st Robin!)

 

FLASH COMICS 1940-49 ---------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Flash/Hawkman/Johnny Thunder)

 

SENSATION COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; 2nd Wonder Woman/1st Wildcat and Mr. Terrific)

 

WHIZ COMICS ------------------------------------------------------------

1 G+

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Captain Marvel)

 

WONDER WOMAN -----------------------------------------------------------

1 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs; origin Wonder Woman)

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nearmint

nearmint

Posted
Posted

Detective 31 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs Slight(P); classic Batman over castle cover 1st Batplane.)

 

Slight resto. Could be a bargain if the PLOD-haters stay away.

 

It's not listed here, but the Larson Action #32 that was recently listed is a very cool book. (thumbs u

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Silver Surfer

Silver Surfer

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

 

 

:o Oh my, I find this much more exciting than the recent Action #1's you guys sold. :popcorn:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nearmint

nearmint

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

 

 

:o Oh my, I find this much more exciting than the recent Action #1's you guys sold. :popcorn:

 

 

det1.8170a.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites
G.A.tor

G.A.tor

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

ACTION COMICS-1938 -----------------------------------------------------

2 FN-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. of Superman)

 

ADVENTURE COMICS 1938-83 -----------------------------------------------

40 FN+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Sandman)

 

ALL AMERICAN COMICS ----------------------------------------------------

16 VG+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Green Lantern classic Shelly-c)

 

ALL STAR COMICS --------------------------------------------------------

3 FN

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Justice Society of America, classic cover)

 

BATMAN -----------------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Joker/1st Catwoman)

2 F/VF

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. Joker/2nd Catwoman Kane & Robinson-c/a)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

30 VG-

(CGC off white pgs 4 pc tape ic; Guardineer-c)

31 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs Slight(P); classic Batman over castle cover 1st Batplane.)

35 VG-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; Classic Hypo/Bondage cover)

38 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Extensive (P); Origin & 1st Robin!)

 

FLASH COMICS 1940-49 ---------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Flash/Hawkman/Johnny Thunder)

 

SENSATION COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; 2nd Wonder Woman/1st Wildcat and Mr. Terrific)

 

WHIZ COMICS ------------------------------------------------------------

1 G+

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Captain Marvel)

 

WONDER WOMAN -----------------------------------------------------------

1 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs; origin Wonder Woman)

 

 

 

holy cow batman....talk about an offering :o
Link to comment
Share on other sites
G.A.tor

G.A.tor

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

 

 

:o Oh my, I find this much more exciting than the recent Action #1's you guys sold. :popcorn:

 

 

det1.8170a.jpg

mine....all MINE
Link to comment
Share on other sites
tonytiger

tonytiger

Posted
Posted
comicconnect's auction is pretty weak. Admittedly, I haven't looked through the whole thing, but that's in part because I made it through several hundred lots without seeing anything worthwhile. The Captain America 100 in 7.0 trimmed was surprising. That's what constitutes an "Event" auction?

 

The following books were added to the auction today: (scans will appear in a few hours)

 

ACTION COMICS-1938 -----------------------------------------------------

2 FN-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. of Superman)

 

ADVENTURE COMICS 1938-83 -----------------------------------------------

40 FN+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Sandman)

 

ALL AMERICAN COMICS ----------------------------------------------------

16 VG+

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Green Lantern classic Shelly-c)

 

ALL STAR COMICS --------------------------------------------------------

3 FN

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Justice Society of America, classic cover)

 

BATMAN -----------------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 1st Joker/1st Catwoman)

2 F/VF

(CGC crm/ow pgs; 2nd app. Joker/2nd Catwoman Kane & Robinson-c/a)

 

DETECTIVE COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

27 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Slight(P); 1st Batman by Bob Kane)

30 VG-

(CGC off white pgs 4 pc tape ic; Guardineer-c)

31 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs Slight(P); classic Batman over castle cover 1st Batplane.)

35 VG-

(CGC crm/ow pgs; Classic Hypo/Bondage cover)

38 VF-

(CGC crm/ow pgs Extensive (P); Origin & 1st Robin!)

 

FLASH COMICS 1940-49 ---------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Flash/Hawkman/Johnny Thunder)

 

SENSATION COMICS -------------------------------------------------------

1 VG/F

(CGC off white pgs; 2nd Wonder Woman/1st Wildcat and Mr. Terrific)

 

WHIZ COMICS ------------------------------------------------------------

1 G+

(CGC off white pgs; Origin & 1st Captain Marvel)

 

WONDER WOMAN -----------------------------------------------------------

1 VF-

(CGC ow/white pgs; origin Wonder Woman)

 

 

 

 

Just a little better than a trimmed Cap 100.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing