TOS 39

[batcollector]

First try at uploading scans, hope this works ...

 

failed

 

See 2nd post

[oakman29]

[batcollector]

2nd try ...

 

[DiceX]

A sweet looking 6.0 to me.

Solid book, technical grade be damned.

 

 

[Thermal]

5.0

[The Silver-Age]

5.5 area

[oakman29]

4.5/5.0 (thumbs u

[AGGIEZ]

5.5

[Dark Knight]

6.5

[Sanj Mitra]

5.0

[Gopher John]

6.0 or 6.5

[Mark 1]

5.5 or 6.0 in hand.

 

I own a 5.0 TOS 39 and yours is a tad nicer.

 

Congrats!

[smithdatura]

With all due respect to oakman, if you're selling that as a 4.5, I'm buying!!!

 

That said, I vote a solid 6.0. Sweet copy of a great key!

[oakman29]

With all due respect to oakman, if you're selling that as a 4.5, I'm buying!!!

 

That said, I vote a solid 6.0. Sweet copy of a great key!

This is a 5.0 max,but diversity is what makes the world go round.

[etanick]

diversitydifference in opinion is what makes the CGC boardworld go roundentertainting.

 

fixed that for you

 

can't go a day with some people thinking CGC is too harsh, too lenient, too something.....

 

[oakman29]

diversitydifference in opinion is what makes the CGC boardworld go roundentertainting.

 

fixed that for you

 

can't go a day with some people thinking CGC is too harsh, too lenient, too something.....

Why thank you kind sir.

[AJD]

I'm with the solid 6.0 brigade. Wouldn't be shocked by a higher grade.

[trmoore54]

This is a classic 5.0/5.5 to me...leaning a little more to the 5.5 side...

If it was my book, I'd probably call it a 6.0...then if I went to put it up for sale I'd advertise it as a 6.0/5.5...then about 30 seconds later I'd pull it back up and edit it to a 5.5/5.0...then later on in the thread I'd guarantee it as a 5.0...

 

The book is too nice for 4.5...as Stevie Borock and Divad have stated (a big guideline for me...although I always felt the same way... )

 

Give the book the highest grade it deserves...and there it is...

[batcollector]

I really appreciate all of the input so far. I plan on getting the book graded and it will be interesting to see how CGC evaluates the grade. I thought the book would be a 5.5.

[Conan_Aficionado]

5.5/6.0