ROUND 6 : Challenge Time

[Rocketeer]

4.5

[nik]

Okay all the grades were recorded, Round 6 is NOW CLOSED. A few of you edited your original guess, Good Thing, 1 of you edited you original guess, BAD THING. I have to admit this was a tough Round, I really expected this book to come back graded similar to my others that I have received, but it came back 2 grades lower .

I will update the NEW Standings very shortly.

[Aces]

Wow...

I actually overgraded for a change.

[Fan4Fan]

Wow...

I actually overgraded for a change.

 

Yeah, me too! Shoulda went with my gut of 4.0... at least that way, I'd be a consistent under-grader...

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

[Aces]

Wow...

I actually overgraded for a change.

 

Yeah, me too! Shoulda went with my gut of 4.0... at least that way, I'd be a consistent under-grader...

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

 

I added a notch to compensate for the GA curve.

I was goning to say 5.0.

That cost me some points.

[jimm94]

Darn. I should have taken a mulligan after all and not third guessed myself.

[sterlingcomics]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

[Mr. Zipper]

I added a notch to compensate for the GA curve.

I was goning to say 5.0. That cost me some points.

 

I did the same, I figured it was a 4.5, then I added .5 as a GA curve. Shoulda left it alone

[sfilosa]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

[ArAich]

I added a notch to compensate for the GA curve.

I was goning to say 5.0. That cost me some points.

 

I did the same, I figured it was a 4.5, then I added .5 as a GA curve. Shoulda left it alone

 

C'mon guys...wasn't your fault...CGC undergraded the dang book...

[sterlingcomics]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

 

Oh yeah, I forgot about that.

[sterlingcomics]

C'mon guys...wasn't your fault...CGC undergraded the dang book...

 

Maybe...maybe not...but I don't think so. Very desirable copy, but a corner chunk out the book, sun shadows, etc takes big dips in the grade. I had a book go down 2+ points because of printer creases---it happens. It is a tough grade for a GA book, I'll give you that.

[Zanarkand]

I didn't spot the piece off the corner until somebody mentioned it.

[nik]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

There was no "Chunk" missing on the bottom

[ArAich]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

There was no "Chunk" missing on the bottom

 

 

You might wanna look at your book again...the bottom right hand corner is missing....

[drbanner]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

There was no "Chunk" missing on the bottom

 

 

You might wanna look at your book again...the bottom right hand corner is missing....

 

Chip, chunk, chunk, chip...big whoop!

[s-man]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

There was no "Chunk" missing on the bottom

 

 

You might wanna look at your book again...the bottom right hand corner is missing....

 

I thought that was just a crease!!!

[uclapeterg]

I asked Nikos about that specifically and he told me that there was no piece missing out of the corner. RECOUNT!

[ultimatevenom]

Best looking 4.5 GA book I've ever seen---I'm guessing the sun shadows killed it.

 

 

I'm betting the chunk out of the bottom right hand corner killed it!!!!!!

There was no "Chunk" missing on the bottom

 

 

You might wanna look at your book again...the bottom right hand corner is missing....

 

I thought that was just a crease!!!

 

It is just a crease

[ArAich]

Piece missing....