Greatest comic ever?

[AJD]

I'm going with this one:

 

 

The pacing is perfect, the characterisation of Scrooge is funny and poignant and the last page is one of the best you'll find.

[sckao]

 

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

 

[DeadOne]

So many great comics already listed.

I 100% agree with Marvel Two-in-One Annual 7 and would like to add X-Men and Teen Titans into the mix. I absolutely loved both these comics when I was younger.

 

[supapimp]

DD 181 from that dbag frank miller.

[HouseofComics.Com]

My usual thoughts tend towards stuff like Batman 1 or Swamp Thing Annual 2 but I have to say, Fables 100 is terrific. Just read that one last night.

[Norrin_Radd]

I'm going with this one:

 

 

The pacing is perfect, the characterisation of Scrooge is funny and poignant and the last page is one of the best you'll find.

I just read it again yesterday. It's hard to choose the greatest Barks comic, so I went with the first. (thumbs u

[Speedy-D]

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

Who did the cover to this one? I know it was Infantino layouts, and Supes looks like Neal Adams...but is it Ross Andru?

[adamstrange]

I'd go with a Carl Barks as well, though my pick might vary from day to day. "A Christmas for Shacktown" or "Ghost of the Grotto" would also work just fine for me.

 

I'm going with this one:

 

 

The pacing is perfect, the characterisation of Scrooge is funny and poignant and the last page is one of the best you'll find.

[Ken Aldred]

Actually, I have a broad-spectrum interest in comics across all Ages,  and so this is a very difficult question.  I find it impossible to remain fixed on a single answer, having been collecting too long and having read far too many brilliant comic books.  There are simply too many parameters involved for just the one book to stand out so clearly.

[Dale Roberts]

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

Who did the cover to this one? I know it was Infantino layouts, and Supes looks like Neal Adams...but is it Ross Andru?

 

Ross Andru with Neal Adams ink assist on the cover

[brendanb438]

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

Who did the cover to this one? I know it was Infantino layouts, and Supes looks like Neal Adams...but is it Ross Andru?

 

Ross Andru with Neal Adams ink assist on the cover

 

 

How would this even be a legit fight? Is Spiderman gonna hide a little kryptonite surprise in his pants for Superman?

[Dale Roberts]

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

Who did the cover to this one? I know it was Infantino layouts, and Supes looks like Neal Adams...but is it Ross Andru?

 

Ross Andru with Neal Adams ink assist on the cover

 

 

How would this even be a legit fight? Is Spiderman gonna hide a little kryptonite surprise in his pants for Superman?

 

Its an excellent story actually. Lex Luthor and Doc Ock are in the same prison. They escape, and Luthor sets one of the heroes up against the other (can't remember, I think he grabs MJ, making it look like Superman, but it might have been Lois). He bathes Spider-man in invisible Red Sun radiation and he kicks Supes but for a while, until it wears off. The two heroes then team up against the villains. Lots of fun.

[Bill Robinson]

Action #1 would be the logical choice.

 

My personal favorites are:

Swamp Thing 27

Sandman 8

ASM 33

[ljmichel-migration]

I will always remember the artistry of Thor 380 whole page and double page scenes and the total domination of the destroyer in Thor 382. Simmonson at his best

[byosti]

I always liked the Hulk 182 story, think it gets overlooked a bit cause of wolvie's brief appearance

[Wally's Comics]

Superman vs The Amazing Spider-man Treasury

 

DC meets Marvel in a gigantic super-sized edition!

 

 

Who did the cover to this one? I know it was Infantino layouts, and Supes looks like Neal Adams...but is it Ross Andru?

 

Ross Andru with Neal Adams ink assist on the cover

 

I got a chance to talk to Neal about this cover and he said he helped Andru a bit with

that superman. He said that the anatomy was off and he didn't want to ink it until it was correct.

 

That's one of the things I liked about Andru's art, his imperfections,

just how I like, in turn, Neal's art as a perfectionist.

 

What an awesome combo.

 

 

[Icculus308win]

 

Probably these two.

 

[CAMPER49]

Interesting that there are a lot of annuals nominated so far.

 

Hard for me to choose, but I guess my pick would be...

 

 

Yep, this is one of my most memorable Barks' work, even though Jack Hannah did about half the pencilling.

[cd4ever]

Marvel Team-Up 38

 

[Ringfinger]

None that I have it seems!