• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Best of 2012!

Started by Hawkman,

44 posts in this topic

Hawkman

Hawkman

Posted
Posted

Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title?

 

2. Best Publisher?

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

 

4. Best Writer?

 

5. Best Artist?

 

6. Best New Villain?

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

 

9. Best New Series?

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

 

11. Best Image Title?

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

 

13. Best DC Title?

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Hawkman

Hawkman

Posted
  • Author
Posted

1. Best Title?

 

Batman

 

2. Best Publisher?

 

Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

 

Upside Down Batman, then jokers return

 

4. Best Writer?

 

Snyder, followed by Hickman

 

5. Best Artist?

 

Capullo

 

6. Best New Villain?

 

Tie between Owls/Negan

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

 

Everything Spiderman related

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

 

Manhatten Projects

 

9. Best New Series?

 

Manhatten Projects

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

 

X-O Manowar

 

11. Best Image Title?

 

WD, followed by MP

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

 

Waid's Daredevil

 

13. Best DC Title?

 

Batman, followed by Detective Comics

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

 

X-O Manowar

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

 

Michonne Special

Link to comment
Share on other sites
paperheart

paperheart

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? Scalped

 

2. Best Publisher? Dark Horse

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Glen as pinata

 

4. Best Writer? Brubaker

 

5. Best Artist? Mike Mignola

 

6. Best New Villain? Negan

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Marvel NOW

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? see #9

 

9. Best New Series? Fatale

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Goon

 

11. Best Image Title? see #9

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Captain America

 

13. Best DC Title? Swamp Thing

 

14. Best Valiant Title? no clue

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jjeanius

jjeanius

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? SAGA

 

2. Best Publisher? IMAGE

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? outside the box on this one...20TH ANNIVERSARY OF IMAGE

 

4. Best Writer? BKV

 

5. Best Artist? RILEY ROSSMO

 

6. Best New Villain? MADDER RED

 

7. Dumbest Moment? EVERYTHING CURRENTLY HAPPENING IN ASM

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? nothing comes to mind.

 

9. Best New Series? BEDLAM

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? THINK TANK (more of a Top Cow book than an Image book). If that doesn't count, then...SIXTH GUN

 

11. Best Image Title? SAGA

 

12. Best Marvel Title? ULTIMATE COMICS: SPIDER-MAN

 

13. Best DC Title? BATMAN

 

14. Best Valiant Title? HARBINGER

Link to comment
Share on other sites
dupont2005

dupont2005

Posted
Posted

 

1. Best Title? Walking Dead is probably the only ongoing that has me excited to go to the comic store every month.

 

2. Best Publisher? Tie between Image and Dark Horse for floppies. For hardcovers and reprints IDW, Dark Horse, Vertigo, and Fantagraphics are all doing well.

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Getting the first two Spaghetti Bros hardcovers for a penny each.

 

4. Best Writer? Jaime Hernandez

 

5. Best Artist? Jaime Hernandez

 

6. Best New Villain? I think Negan was the only notable villain introduced this year in any of my comics.

 

7. Dumbest Moment? I try to not read comics I don't like. I know I bought one or two this year, just can't remember.

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? The new Stumptown!

 

9. Best New Series? I don't think I picked up a new ongoing this year.

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Usagi Yojimbo

 

11. Best Image Title? Walking Dead

 

12. Best Marvel Title? I don't think I read any

 

13. Best DC Title? If Vertigo counts then American Vampire

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Don't read any.

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? The Michonne special might be the only one I picked up this year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
comicsnyc22

comicsnyc22

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title?

 

TWD-- really came back well this year

 

2. Best Publisher?

 

DC's New 52 sustained the industry and helped inject some nice juice into the category overall

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

 

Glenn in TWD #100. Ooof.

 

4. Best Writer?

Scott Snyder

 

 

5. Best Artist?

Ivan Reis, duh

 

 

6. Best New Villain?

 

Madder Red.

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

 

n/a

 

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

 

n/a

 

9. Best New Series?

 

tough one, but Saga or ToT by a longshot. Fatale is pretty great, too. Great year for Image

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

 

TMNT

 

11. Best Image Title?

 

TOT

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

 

Daredevil

 

13. Best DC Title?

 

Batman, with Aquaman a close 2

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

 

n/a

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Hardcore

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
buddymagoo

buddymagoo

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title?

INVINCIBLE

 

2. Best Publisher?

IMAGE

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

ALANA GIVING BIRTH TO HAZEL AND SAGA

 

4. Best Writer?

KIRKMAN (FOR INVINCIBLE AND THE WALKING DEAD)

 

5. Best Artist?

GABRIEL RODRIGUEZ

 

6. Best New Villain?

COURT OF OWLS

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

SACKING GAIL SIMONE

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

HAPPY

 

9. Best New Series?

SAGA

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

LOCKE & KEY

 

11. Best Image Title?

INVINCIBLE

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

ALL NEW X-MEN

 

13. Best DC Title?

BATMAN

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

HARBINGER

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

WILD CHILDREN

Link to comment
Share on other sites
fastballspecial

fastballspecial

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title?

Batman

 

2. Best Publisher?

Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

Death of Glen

 

4. Best Writer?

Tim Seeley

 

5. Best Artist?

Jim Lee

 

6. Best New Villain?

Negan is there really anyone else?

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

Gail Simone giving the boot how stupid.

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

Colder currently

 

9. Best New Series?

Revival

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

Revival

 

11. Best Image Title?

Revival

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

Hawkeye

 

13. Best DC Title?

Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

X-O

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

GL Annual

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Venom

Venom

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title?

Thief of Thieves

 

2. Best Publisher?

Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

Return of Joker

4. Best Writer?

Rick Remender

5. Best Artist?

Ryan Stegman

6. Best New Villain?

Owls

7. Dumbest Moment?

ASM 698-700 or Firing Gail Simone and rehiring her

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

Happy

9. Best New Series?

Thief of Thieves

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

Ex Sanguine

11. Best Image Title?

Thief of Thieves

12. Best Marvel Title?

Amazing Spider-man or All New X-men

13. Best DC Title?

Batman

14. Best Valiant Title?

N/A

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

N/A

Link to comment
Share on other sites
aszumilo

aszumilo

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? Batman

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Death of Glenn (WD)

 

4. Best Writer? Snyder (Batman)

 

5. Best Artist? Capullo

 

6. Best New Villain? Madder Red / Owls

 

7. Dumbest Moment? ASM - "Death of Peter Parker"

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Alabaster Wolves

 

9. Best New Series? Saga

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Grim Ghost (When it is actually published)

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga / Revival

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Mighty Thor / Daredevil

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? None - Don't read Valiant

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Batman Annual

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Garf

Garf

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? TWD

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? The climax of The Boys

 

4. Best Writer? Robert Kirkman / Cullen Bunn

 

5. Best Artist? Jeremy Bastian / CPW III

 

6. Best New Villain? Owls

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Peter Panzerfaust hype... I just don't get it (shrug)

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy

 

9. Best New Series? Revival

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? The Sixth Gun / The Stuff of Legend (recently)

 

11. Best Image Title? TWD

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Don't really read them regularly enough.

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Don't read them.

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? zzz

Link to comment
Share on other sites
I like pie

I like pie

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? Saga

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? umbilical cord removal via teeth

 

4. Best Writer? BKV

 

5. Best Artist? Fiona Staples

 

6. Best New Villain? Madder Red

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Spider Man/Doc Oct silliness

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy

 

9. Best New Series? Bedlam

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? There's other companies?

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga/Bedlam

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Daredevil

 

13. Best DC Title d34fc96f.gif

 

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Tried them in the 90's

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? N/A

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Beige

Beige

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? - Peter Panzerfaust (try a second reading, 3 or 4 at a go)

 

2. Best Publisher? - Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? - Death of Glenn (TWD)

 

4. Best Writer? - Kurtis Wiebe

 

5. Best Artist? - Joe Wight

 

6. Best New Villain? - Negan

 

7. Dumbest Moment? - ASM #700 arc

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? - Nazi Zombies

 

9. Best New Series? - Peter Panzerfaust

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? - The Last Zombie

 

11. Best Image Title? - Peter Panzerfaust

 

12. Best Marvel Title? - Haven't bought one all year

 

13. Best DC Title? - Haven't bought one all year

 

14. Best Valiant Title? - Haven't bought one all year

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? - My Little Pony - Dr Hooves - quite clever!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KONG

KONG

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

1. Best Title? Twd

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Hmmm

 

4. Best Writer? Hickman

 

5. Best Artist? Wrightson

 

6. Best New Villain? Megan

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Wonder woman kiss in flight

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy

 

9. Best New Series? Manhattan Projects

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Frankenstein Alive Alive or Mars Attacks

 

11. Best Image Title? TWD

 

12. Best Marvel Title? The one choked full of all the ads. Never mind

 

13. Best DC Title? If vertigo counts Django unchained.

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Pass

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Poyo!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nexus

Nexus

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Frank Castle's exit in PUNISHERMAX.

 

4. Best Writer? Jonathan Hickman

 

5. Best Artist? Eric Powell

 

6. Best New Villain? Negan

 

7. Dumbest Moment? BEFORE WATCHMEN or Swamp Thing retcon

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Not technically a mini, but reads like one: PUNISHERMAX

 

9. Best New Series? THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? LOCKE AND KEY

 

11. Best Image Title? THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS

 

12. Best Marvel Title? FURY MAX

 

13. Best DC Title? SWEET TOOTH

 

14. Best Valiant Title? N/A

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? The Artist's Edition line from IDW

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BeerThirty

BeerThirty

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? Manhattan Projects

 

2. Best Publisher? Image- by a lot

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? The end of the first heist in Thief of Thieves

 

4. Best Writer? Ed Brubaker - between Fatale and his marvel stuff, a great year

 

5. Best Artist? Rob Guillory - IMO, carried Chew through a pretty slow year plot-wise. His improvement since chew 1 is remarkable

 

6. Best New Villain? Robert Oppenheimer in Manhattan Projects

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Secret unable to make its deadlines

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Spaceman

 

9. Best New Series? This year was ridiculous for new titles. Manhattan projects, but saga & Fatale were ridiculous.

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Didn't read any

 

11. Best Image Title? Manhattan projects

 

12. Best Marvel Title? I really dug rucka's punisher

 

13. Best DC Title? Don't read

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Don't read

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? The only one I read was secret agent Poyo. Sorry, Jerel, but I didn't think it was that good. Chew 30 showed how good chew can be.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ItsJustRyan

ItsJustRyan

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? Think Tank

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Death of Glenn (most profound/important)

 

4. Best Writer? Hawkins (think tank), Snyder (batman), Kirkman

 

5. Best Artist? Rahsan Ekedal (think tank), Fiona Staples (Saga)

 

6. Best New Villain? Negan (a-hole), new Joker

 

7. Dumbest Moment? Alien testicles (Saga 7)

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy!

 

9. Best New Series? Saga

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Other title exist outside Image, Marvel, and DC??

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga (Think Tank close second)

 

12. Best Marvel Title? New X-Men

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman (duh)

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Non-reader (apologies to fans)

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

. Secret Agent Poyo (Chew)

 

 

Ryan

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing