• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Best of 2012!

Started by Hawkman,

44 posts in this topic

400yrs

400yrs

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title?

 

Saga

 

2. Best Publisher?

 

Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

 

ASM 698

 

4. Best Writer?

 

BKV

 

5. Best Artist?

 

Staples

 

6. Best New Villain?

 

The Will

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

 

Iron Man 1

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

 

?

 

9. Best New Series?

 

Saga

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

 

Harbinger

 

11. Best Image Title?

 

Saga

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

 

Hawkeye

 

13. Best DC Title?

 

Swamp Thing

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

 

Harbinger

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

 

Poyo!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
plasticmoz

plasticmoz

Posted
Posted
Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title?

 

Batman

 

2. Best Publisher?

 

Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

 

--

 

4. Best Writer?

 

Snyder (Batman, American Vampire)

 

5. Best Artist?

 

Capullo

6. Best New Villain?

 

Oppenheimer in MP

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

 

ASM 698-700 madness

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

 

Severed (started 2011)

 

9. Best New Series?

 

Fatale

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

 

American Vampire

 

11. Best Image Title?

 

Fatale

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

 

Daredevil, UXF

 

13. Best DC Title?

 

Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

 

--

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ramses717

Ramses717

Posted
Posted

Reply with your following responses to these questions:

 

 

1. Best Title? Batman

 

2. Best Publisher? Image Comics

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? The Will squashes the pimps' head with his bare hands - Saga 4

 

4. Best Writer? Scott Snyder

 

5. Best Artist? Greg Capullo

 

6. Best New Villain? Court of Owls

 

7. Dumbest Moment? The Superior Spider-Man

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Dawn of the Jedi: Force Storm

 

9. Best New Series? Saga

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Dawn of the Jedi

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga

 

12. Best Marvel Title? All New X-Men

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? NA

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Batman Annual 1

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mystrymachine

mystrymachine

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title?

Walking Dead

 

2. Best Publisher?

Image- By a longshot,

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment?

Glen gets *sob* I can't say it.

 

 

4. Best Writer?

Kirkman

 

5. Best Artist?

meh...

 

6. Best New Villain?

Madder Red

 

7. Dumbest Moment?

Secret Agent Poyo

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series?

The only one I have read is Planetoid.

 

9. Best New Series?

Manhatten Projects

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title?

Sixth Gun

 

11. Best Image Title?

Walking Dead

 

12. Best Marvel Title?

uggh...still looking for one.

 

13. Best DC Title?

Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title?

Harbinger

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special?

Mars Attacks Popeye

 

 

 

Top

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Underground44

Underground44

Posted
Posted

 

1. Best Title? Punk Rock Jesus / Think Tank

 

2. Best Publisher? Image Comics

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? The art in Punk Rock Jesus... It's up there with the best I've ever seen.

 

4. Best Writer? Sean Murphy (PRJ). Hawkins (Think Tank)

 

5. Best Artist? Sean Murphy by a mile.

 

6. Best New Villain? Madder Red

 

7. Dumbest Moment? 6 billion variants for Bedlam #1

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Punk Rock Jesus

 

9. Best New Series? Revival

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Lookouts

 

11. Best Image Title? Revival

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Mark Waids Daredevil

 

13. Best DC Title? Punk Rock Jesus (D/C Vertigo)

 

14. Best Valiant Title? NA

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? L'il Homer or Ralph Wiggum from Bongo

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Mr. Solo Dolo

Mr. Solo Dolo

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? Saga

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Glenn meets Lucille.

 

4. Best Writer? BKV

 

5. Best Artist? Fiona Staples

 

6. Best New Villain? Madder Red, Cyclops

 

7. Dumbest Moment? ASM 700. damn spolier!

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy!

 

9. Best New Series? Hawkguy. Revival. Bedlam

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Top Cow's Think Tank

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga, Revival, TWD, Bedlam

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Hawkguy.

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? n/a

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Secret Agent Poyo

Link to comment
Share on other sites
troydivision1

troydivision1

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? Saga

2. Best Publisher? Image

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Saga #6 - Page 6, Panel 4

4. Best Writer? Brian K. Vaughan

5. Best Artist? Covers: Jenny Frison / Interiors: Fiona Staples

6. Best New Villain? Prince Robot IV

7. Dumbest Moment? Killing Peter Parker, again...

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Everyone Loves Tank Girl

9. Best New Series? Saga

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Adventure Time

11. Best Image Title? Saga

12. Best Marvel Title? Uncanny X-Force

13. Best DC Title? Batman

14. Best Valiant Title? Shadowman

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? House of Fun

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nexus

Nexus

Posted
Posted

CBR ranks the top 100 comics of 2012. Here's the top 10:

 

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=42909

 

(Links to #'s 11-100 are in the article.)

 

Everyone who picked SAGA will be happy to know that it's been anointed #1 by CBR! It was #2 for me...my #1 (THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS) places #7. Another title I enjoy, PROPHET, is #5.

 

Some other Image titles that have shown up a lot in this thread such as THINK TANK (which I enjoy), BEDLAM (not so much), and PETER PANZERFAUST don't place in the top 100, unfortunately. REVIVAL, however, comes in at #25 and THIEF OF THIEVES comes in at #32.

 

We're not all going to agree, of course, but a fun list to check out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ChrisInBaltimore

ChrisInBaltimore

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? Saga or Batman

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Reading the first issue of Saga

 

4. Best Writer? Kirkman

 

5. Best Artist? Greg Capullo

 

6. Best New Villain? Negan

 

7. Dumbest Moment? ASM Dying Wish

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Stumptown was the only mini I can think of. I think the Daredevil: End of Days is pretty good but it just started.

 

9. Best New Series? Saga or Hawkeye

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Buffy- but that is only because it is the only title I read that I think fits in the category... Vertigo doesn't count right?

 

11. Best Image Title? Saga

 

12. Best Marvel Title? Hawkeye

 

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? I don't read any.

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? None stand out...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Holden Caulfield

Holden Caulfield

Posted
Posted

1. Best Title? Thief of Thieves

 

2. Best Publisher? Image

 

3. Best Comic Book Moment? Return of the Joker

4. Best Writer? Kirkman

 

5. Best Artist? Alex Ross

 

6. Best New Villain? Does a Psychotic Joker with a Strap-on (face) count?

 

7. Dumbest Moment? STU-PI-DI-ER SPIDER-MAN

 

8. Favorite Mini-Series? Happy

 

9. Best New Series? SAGA

 

10. Favorite Non-DC/Marvel/Image Title? Top Cow - Think Tank

 

11. Best Image Title? Thief of Thieves

 

12. Best Marvel Title? IS there one at the moment???

13. Best DC Title? Batman

 

14. Best Valiant Title? Shadowman

 

15. Favorite One Shot/Special? Didn't do any shots...well not books :whistle:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Underground44

Underground44

Posted
Posted
CBR ranks the top 100 comics of 2012. Here's the top 10:

 

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=42909

 

(Links to #'s 11-100 are in the article.)

 

Everyone who picked SAGA will be happy to know that it's been anointed #1 by CBR! It was #2 for me...my #1 (THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS) places #7. Another title I enjoy, PROPHET, is #5.

 

Some other Image titles that have shown up a lot in this thread such as THINK TANK (which I enjoy), BEDLAM (not so much), and PETER PANZERFAUST don't place in the top 100, unfortunately. REVIVAL, however, comes in at #25 and THIEF OF THIEVES comes in at #32.

 

We're not all going to agree, of course, but a fun list to check out.

 

Nice to see Punk Rock Jesus make the top 20 also (#17)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ItsJustRyan

ItsJustRyan

Posted
Posted
CBR ranks the top 100 comics of 2012. Here's the top 10:

 

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=42909

 

(Links to #'s 11-100 are in the article.)

 

Everyone who picked SAGA will be happy to know that it's been anointed #1 by CBR! It was #2 for me...my #1 (THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS) places #7. Another title I enjoy, PROPHET, is #5.

 

Some other Image titles that have shown up a lot in this thread such as THINK TANK (which I enjoy), BEDLAM (not so much), and PETER PANZERFAUST don't place in the top 100, unfortunately. REVIVAL, however, comes in at #25 and THIEF OF THIEVES comes in at #32.

 

We're not all going to agree, of course, but a fun list to check out.

 

Nice to see Punk Rock Jesus make the top 20 also (#17)

 

Just reviewed the list a realize I missed out on a lot of titles... Future trades to be discovered and picked up used.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Underground44

Underground44

Posted
Posted
CBR ranks the top 100 comics of 2012. Here's the top 10:

 

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=42909

 

(Links to #'s 11-100 are in the article.)

 

Everyone who picked SAGA will be happy to know that it's been anointed #1 by CBR! It was #2 for me...my #1 (THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS) places #7. Another title I enjoy, PROPHET, is #5.

 

Some other Image titles that have shown up a lot in this thread such as THINK TANK (which I enjoy), BEDLAM (not so much), and PETER PANZERFAUST don't place in the top 100, unfortunately. REVIVAL, however, comes in at #25 and THIEF OF THIEVES comes in at #32.

 

We're not all going to agree, of course, but a fun list to check out.

 

Nice to see Punk Rock Jesus make the top 20 also (#17)

 

Just reviewed the list a realize I missed out on a lot of titles... Future trades to be discovered and picked up used.

 

That's what I love most about those lists... Discovering books that you've completely missed for whatever reason

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ChrisInBaltimore

ChrisInBaltimore

Posted
Posted
CBR ranks the top 100 comics of 2012. Here's the top 10:

 

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=42909

 

(Links to #'s 11-100 are in the article.)

 

Everyone who picked SAGA will be happy to know that it's been anointed #1 by CBR! It was #2 for me...my #1 (THE MANHATTAN PROJECTS) places #7. Another title I enjoy, PROPHET, is #5.

 

Some other Image titles that have shown up a lot in this thread such as THINK TANK (which I enjoy), BEDLAM (not so much), and PETER PANZERFAUST don't place in the top 100, unfortunately. REVIVAL, however, comes in at #25 and THIEF OF THIEVES comes in at #32.

 

We're not all going to agree, of course, but a fun list to check out.

 

Nice to see Punk Rock Jesus make the top 20 also (#17)

 

Just reviewed the list a realize I missed out on a lot of titles... Future trades to be discovered and picked up used.

 

That's what I love most about those lists... Discovering books that you've completely missed for whatever reason

 

Yea I was amazed how many of those books I've never heard of or seen. I'm intrigued by a lot of them too.

 

CBR reviews are all over the place sometimes though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing