PGM: ASM #1- Test Your Skill - Book is slabbed - See Page 5 for Better pic

[oakman29]

I'm in that 6.0/6.5 area too,regardless a very well presenting book.

[Diaolos]

Keep your thoughts coming. I will post the answer tomorrow night around 8pm EST

[timfinz]

Keep your thoughts coming. I will post the answer tomorrow night around 8pm EST

[Supa-Bad-Mofo]

6.0

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

6.0 / 6.5

 

Pretty book. I wouldn't sig it.

 

 

[mdube16]

7.0 and no signature please!

[anstettoman]

first time i've guessed at a book 6.5 w/white pages cool!!!

[rjpb]

The photos are better than the scan, but it's still impossible to fully judge, and I can't tell if there is anything more than the chipping, the small divot at the bottom, and the color breaking crease through the blue circle, and maybe one through Ben ( if that isn't a slab scratch) . While CGC is overly forgiving of chipping, I don't know that they are consistently so.

 

4.5

[Diaolos]

7.0 and no signature please!

 

Are you saying I should not break the slab and get Stan Lee to sign it?

[Diaolos]

6.0 / 6.5

 

Pretty book. I wouldn't sig it.

 

 

Hmmm a few people are saying I should not sig it. Curious as to the why. Would the book not be more desirable and they more valuable? I am even thinking of a press.

 

Everyon'e thought are welcomed and appreciated

[jaybuck43]

Book looks nicer than my 6.5. I'd say 7.0/7.5

[mdube16]

7.0 and no signature please!

 

Are you saying I should not break the slab and get Stan Lee to sign it?

 

Yes thats my thought. Stan is an icon but he signs a lot. I think you limit your market if you ever want to sell by having him sign it.

[Thanos88]

6.0

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

IMO ...

 

A press will not help the grade and SL's Sig (too many) will not help the value. Years ago Sigs were really cool on SA books but today they are everywhere.

 

I would leave this beautiful book as it is and be very proud of it .... as it is. (thumbs u

 

 

[Diaolos]

IMO ...

 

A press will not help the grade and SL's Sig (too many) will not help the value. Years ago Sigs were really cool on SA books but today they are everywhere.

 

I would leave this beautiful book as it is and be very proud of it .... as it is. (thumbs u

 

 

You have a point. I panic when I have to put a book like this in the mail. May it's worth keeping it universal. So confused now

[Diaolos]

Here is a recap of what people are saying:

 

 

4.5 = 2

5.0 = 2

5.0/5.5 = 1

5.5 = 2

6.0 = 6

6.0/6.5 = 2

6.5 = 4

7.0 = 2

7.0/7.5 = 1

 

 

 

[kav]

I'm going with 8.0

[stanley1883]

I'd still like a better picture so I can guess with absolute certainty, however as is....6.0/6.5 range but I'll give it a 6.5.

[Hado]

I'm in with the 7.0's

[Spider-Dan]

6.5/7.0