PGM - ACTION COMICS 252 1ST SUPERGIRL - GRADE IS IN

[jsilverjanet]

 

 

4.0 CREAM PAGES

 

 

book is complete, damage is on the cover (bottom FC some color loss) and a tear on the back cover

 

need to check is that's water damage on the back cover

 

thoughts? thanks!

 

[topofthetotem]

3.5 sweet book!

[Wipple]

3.0 IMHO. Rips stains bring it down, but one of my favorite books in any grade. RIP Al Plastino

[DR.X]

that does look like a stain and there was water damage and color loss in the green on the bottom edge, and that corner.

 

no better than 3.0 for me, but still a presentable copy.

[faster friends]

Has it been pressed already?

[jsilverjanet]

Has it been pressed already?

nope

[Hulksdaddy1]

3.0-3.5. Nice looking book, present very well.

[faster friends]

3.5

[timfinz]

3.0 IMHO!

[kav]

Strange cvr-looks like Curt Swan drew everything but Superman's face - that looks like Boring...

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

3.0

 

 

[tjanse]

Tired but 3.0 seems fair

[jsilverjanet]

submitted 2 copies and this one got a half point less than my other copy which looked like a solid 5.0 or greater.

 

neither book was pressed.

 

the score given for this book was accurate (seller was worldwide comics) though they got the page quality wrong (cr/ow)

[Mijael.Levy]

with the rips and the water stain the book falls to the good area but looks better than good, so i think its a 3.0

[AnhDepTrai]

4.0