PGM ST 111

[seredynskib]

I picked this copy up at C2E2 yesterday and since I've been wanting to add ST111 to my collection for a while now, I'm happy with it.

 

I asked the seller what he thought the book was graded and he suggested it was a 5.0. My personal opinion was 3.5.

 

Major flaws: Tear at top of spine. Tear at top staple (still attached to cover and centerfold). Bottom staple rust. Small piece of top right edge of cover missing.

 

I'm curious how you guys would grade the book:

 

 

 

 

[SNiPER]

3.0 on a good day. IMHO

[kav]

5.0

Was it Kermit's Pad?

[stanley1883]

5.0

Was it Kermit's Pad?

 

The prodigal son returns!!!!!!

[seredynskib]

5.0

Was it Kermit's Pad?

 

It was not. If you need to know who, PM me...

 

Any other guesses on the grade please?

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

3.0

 

Another major flaw is about 3/4 of the bottom bc as some serious impact issues. And there are numerous minor flaws that are accountable as well.

 

This is really a very pretty book. You don't see many 3.0s that look this good.

 

But not a 5.0 by any means,... except maybe at a presentable distance.

 

Sorry!

 

 

 

[kav]

5.0

Was it Kermit's Pad?

 

The prodigal son returns!!!!!!

[makeminemego]

3.0-3.5, but like someone else said, it presents better than that.

[southerncross]

im at 4.5, many creases as noted on the back cover, if they were on the front cover a 3 would come into play (thumbs u

[seredynskib]

I appreciate everyone's input thus far, thank you!

[comicjack]

Has all the makings of 4.0 my 2 cents

[Conan_Aficionado]

3.0/3.5 tops with that epic staple pull.

[burntboy]

BC isn't too great but I'm still thinking maybe a 4.0. Front cover image is quite nice...

[seredynskib]

This book arrived back from CGC last week as a 3.0. Thanks again for everyone who guessed its grade several months ago!