PGM: X-Men 1 (2 copies)

[rec1978]

Guys,

 

I just wanted to see what you think the grades would be on 2 separate copies of X-Men 1; per the Seller of each, neither book has had any Restoration:

 

Xmen 1 A Front

 

 

Xmen 1 A Back

 

 

Xmen 1 B Front

 

 

Xmen 1 B Back

 

 

 

[timfinz]

X-Men #1 Copy A = 6.5 IMHO

X-Men #1 Copy B = 6.5 IMHO

[Red84]

7 and 6.5

[Vision75]

I'm at a 7.0 for the first copy. Several smallish flasw, but overall presents well. I had a 6.5 at one time, and number 1 is definitely better.

 

A 6.0 for the second copy. The top 1/3 of the spine looks pretty damaged.

 

Nice books. Wouldn't mind having them.

[rec1978]

Thanks, all!

[Erndog]

Pretty close actually.

 

My guess was 7.0 for the first one and 6.5 for the second. Though I could see a half grade higher for each. Colors are a lot better in the first one.

 

Really nice books.

[Conan_Aficionado]

6.5/7.0 for the first

 

and 5.5 second, what's going on in the upper part of the spine???

[Ghost Rider]

7.0 and 6.5 IMHO

[paperheart]

6.5 and 4.5

[makeminemego]

6.5 and 5.0.

[rec1978]

Thank you to all!