Program Human Torch #6

[Manray]

A Human Torch #6 that I would like to have assessed by the forum before sale. Please note the 1.5 mm pinhole that runs cleanly through the upper left corner of the whole book as well as the pencil writings in the "H" of Human Torch. Otherwise pages internally are white, intact, and no tears.Thank you in advance.

http://i1074.photobucket.com/albums/w419/rayraff87/Scan0009_zpsunch66ge.jpg

 

[/url]

 

http://i1074.photobucket.com/albums/w419/rayraff87/Scan0010_zps6auwmwcy.jpg

 

[/url]

[ninanina]

Without the hole and because of the age of the comic I'll go 7.5...and only because of the minor spine roll that I don't notice on the front, but is quite evident when you see the back cover.

 

I have no idea how a hole through the entire comic effects the grade. We're gonna' have to hear from some forumites with a bit more knowledge on this.

 

4.0 with the hole....a qualified 7.5?

 

I have no idea

 

Maybe if you get enough opinions, you can figure it out.

 

 

 

 

[kav]

I say 5.0

7.5 minus 2.5 for the hole

[makeminemego]

I remember an FF 1 that was Q7.0 due to 3 similar holes from what I am assuming was binder storage. I wonder if something like that may be in order for this book.

[kav]

fyi PGM= "Please Grade My"

[Primetime]

4.0

[Dick Pontoon]

PGM stands for "Please Grade My" not "Program."

[Manray]

Thank you all for the input. Ninanina, I did not appreciate the slight spine roll until you pointed it out. Nice pick up. I will follow up with results of grading if I go in that direction. [sorry about the "PGM" becoming "Program" - forgot to turn off my text expander.]

[lhcomics]

I would say 6.0 even with the hole.

 

Think about it. The amount of cover paper loss due to the hole in minor. Now on the interior I bet if you add up the paper loss from every page it would be about the size of a quarter.

 

If you had a 7.0/7.5 comic with a quarter size piece out of a page margin would it grade less than 6.0?

 

My logic anyway. Beautiful comic. Thanks for sharing

[Point Five]

I would say 6.0 even with the hole.

 

Think about it. The amount of cover paper loss due to the hole in minor. Now on the interior I bet if you add up the paper loss from every page it would be about the size of a quarter.

 

If you had a 7.0/7.5 comic with a quarter size piece out of a page margin would it grade less than 6.0?

 

My logic anyway. Beautiful comic. Thanks for sharing

I see where you're coming from, but in that scenario I'd prefer a book with a hole in one page (within reason...) than a book with a hole through every page.

 

I'll guess 5.5, but a 6.0 from CGC wouldn't surprise me. It's an absolute stunner.