General discussion thread - keep the other threads clean 29 29

[newshane]

Just now, Red84 said:

If someone is going to pick and choose self-serving data then that disingenuous use of gpa should be called out in their sales thread.

This is fine with me. 

[Red84]

Just now, newshane said:

I agree. But it's pretty easy to out these people since GPA data is open to the public as long as they have a subscription, and I don't think we need to add another rule and another reason to have threads pulled. 

People seem to have a very hard time following the rules we've already established. 

People also tend to "bend" census numbers, but all it takes is a quick check on the part of the buyer to see what's going on. 

Fair enough.

[newshane]

1 minute ago, Red84 said:

If someone cites gpa for a 3.0 most recent sale of $2500 then I should be able to respond in the thread that a 4.0 just sold for $2000.

 

I think a better choice would be to PM and use the data in negotiations. 

My whole feel is that the buyer should beware and the buyer should be responsible. 

[Red84]

1 minute ago, newshane said:

I think a better choice would be to PM and use the data in negotiations. 

My whole feel is that the buyer should beware and the buyer should be responsible. 

It's the whole snake oil salesmanship that bothers me.

[newshane]

Personally, I don't blindly throw up the before:

1. Checking the census

2. Checking eBay

3. Checking GPA 

I'm not foolish enough to blindly trust my car salesman or anyone else trying to make a dollar. I gather data, conduct research, and arrive at a decision to buy or pass. 

And yes, I sometimes chuckle at the way people build up their "deals" after looking at the numbers. In the end, I just move along. If someone else is foolish enough to take the bait, it's none of my business. 

I don't like predatory sellers either, but I do believe people should act like responsible adults before buying anything. 

[newshane]

2 minutes ago, Red84 said:

It's the whole snake oil salesmanship that bothers me.

To be clear, it bothers me as well. 

But I don't feel the need to nanny everyone down the pike. 

I think we should all focus on enforcing the rules as they stand instead of adding to the plate. Unfortunately, it would just be another rule that most people would ignore. 

...and to be fair, I've seen a lot of sellers who are very honest and direct when it comes to quoting GPA. 

And $10 a month is not a lot to pay for the peace of mind offered by GPA data. 

[KPR Comics]

11 minutes ago, Red84 said:

Then I propose that if a seller chooses to list a gpa price that the community be free to respond with additional gpa price quotes within the thread.

If someone cites gpa for a 3.0 most recent sale of $2500 then I should be able to respond in the thread that a 4.0 just sold for $2000.

If someone is going to pick and choose self-serving data then that disingenuous use of gpa should be called out in their sales thread.

100% agree

[skypinkblu]

1 hour ago, newshane said:

No need for another rule. 

The buyer is free to: 

1. Ignore the numbers

2. Check for themselves

 

While I somewhat agree about not making more rules, I like to think that we watch out for each other here, or at least we used to.  I see way too many people "enhancing" the perceived value of things and some people here do tend to be trusting because they feel it's a collecting site.

Personally I have mispriced a number of books on the lower side, because even though I do research, there just isn't that much information. Sometimes I just paid very little for a copy, so I price it low deliberately, but not always.  No one ever says...WOW you priced that way too low, why don't you raise the price before someone takes it;)  lol. ? 

 

Since comics have gone up so much, a lot of the members here have changed. There is a completely different mentality for those who are merely here to flip and make a profit.  Many may be perfectly nice people, but I miss a lot of the "collector helping collector" stuff. It's just a lot more heartwarming than the "hey you were too dumb to figure out what you had and I'm a genius so I win" stuff.

I suppose that one way to make things better would be to educate people more. Maybe some of us should start threads on "Page Quality Vs Prices", "How GPA is not the end all of pricing on scarce stuff", "Where to look stuff up other than on GPA and eBay" , etc.

Honestly, I knew NONE of that stuff 13 years ago.

 

[Red84]

13 minutes ago, skypinkblu said:

While I somewhat agree about not making more rules, I like to think that we watch out for each other here, or at least we used to.  I see way too many people "enhancing" the perceived value of things and some people here do tend to be trusting because they feel it's a collecting site.

Personally I have mispriced a number of books on the lower side, because even though I do research, there just isn't that much information. Sometimes I just paid very little for a copy, so I price it low deliberately, but not always.  No one ever says...WOW you priced that way too low, why don't you raise the price before someone takes it;)  lol. ? 

 

Since comics have gone up so much, a lot of the members here have changed. There is a completely different mentality for those who are merely here to flip and make a profit.  Many may be perfectly nice people, but I miss a lot of the "collector helping collector" stuff. It's just a lot more heartwarming than the "hey you were too dumb to figure out what you had and I'm a genius so I win" stuff.

I suppose that one way to make things better would be to educate people more. Maybe some of us should start threads on "Page Quality Vs Prices", "How GPA is not the end all of pricing on scarce stuff", "Where to look stuff up other than on GPA and eBay" , etc.

Honestly, I knew NONE of that stuff 13 years ago.

 

It's the sense of community that makes the snake oil salesmanship more dangerous. It gets people to let down their guard and rely on the false or deceptive statements made by some sellers.

That's why I don't like any mention of gpa in sales threads. It creates a false sense of security within the community that the information being provided is accurate.

[miraclemet]

Im one of the people who is quick to PM someone who is mis-using GPA data. 

Stating 12mo and 90 day data isnt misusing it especially in cases with multiple data points even if there's some PQ variables... as the Pickers say "I cant do the buying AND the seling" there is some onus on the buyer to determine if the deal is good and the info is good. 

Jumping on an outlier data point due to a BIN (or as we know occasionally people attempt to manipulate GPA via fraudulent BINs) while ignoring the 90 day and 12mo data is sketchy, and I'll often PM people about it if it looks like a grey area move. 

Also when dealing with few data points it's often better to point out surrounding grade data that might be more recent along with the in-grade data that might be older. 

[NP_Gresham]

6 hours ago, Red84 said:

Then I propose that if a seller chooses to list a gpa price that the community be free to respond with additional gpa price quotes within the thread.

 

There IS a rule against that. We call that thread krapping around here.

I totally agree with your sentiments - GPA is the best service I have ever paid for- but additional rules are not needed. Common sense can not be made into a rule. At some point the protections are there and it is caveat emptor.

 

[Bomber-Bob]

6 hours ago, Red84 said:

My view is that giving out of context gpa quotes is equivalent to flat out lying.

This. The data can be interpreted in many ways and only using selective data to benefit your sale is, IMO, not appropriate. 

[Bomber-Bob]

20 minutes ago, NP_Gresham said:

There IS a rule against that. We call that thread krapping around here.

I totally agree with your sentiments - GPA is the best service I have ever paid for- but additional rules are not needed. Common sense can not be made into a rule. At some point the protections are there and it is caveat emptor.

 

That's why I came here to vent, respecting the threadkrap. AND I did not ask or even hint at a new rule. I came here to say 'I hate it when' . IMO, the seller was not comparing apples to apples. He had a CR/OW book. He should be comparing it to other CR/OW books, not to averages. He said it doesn't matter unless the pages are Brittle. I respectfully disagree.

[Red84]

30 minutes ago, NP_Gresham said:

There IS a rule against that. We call that thread krapping around here.

I totally agree with your sentiments - GPA is the best service I have ever paid for- but additional rules are not needed. Common sense can not be made into a rule. At some point the protections are there and it is caveat emptor.

 

I know there’s a rule against it. That’s why I was proposing that people be permitted to counter the out of context gpa quotes without it qualifying as threadkrapping. 

[skypinkblu]

It would not be "threadkrapping" if someone offered the information here in the discussion thread, but not everyone looks here. 

[crassus]

The issue of "threadkrapping" is a difficult one. Generally I consider it a very necessary rule and one that should be interpreted broadly and strictly. That said, experience shows that the rule can vanish when any whiff of "scam" shows up in a sales thread.  The "outing" of a scammer seems different, except that sometimes the scammer gets outed only gradually based on suspicions which begin as awkward questions posted in a sales thread. 

And some questions are not always awkward, but may be reasonable given the presentation. So with the GPA question, would it be threadkrapping, let's say, to post something like, "Hi, nice book and thanks for the sales info, but I don't have GPA so could you show us the figures you are working with?" Is this different from asking a seller who is posting expensive books with fuzzy pics in a bag to please post better pictures fc and bc outside of a bag? I might think the second example  has a bit more of a negative implication than the first one, but that would depend I guess on the seller. If the latter is not "threadkrapping" than neither can the first, since the logic of both is the same, i.e. the buyer is asking for clarification and further information about the book(s). The seller does not have to provide GPA, but once they do the door is opened up to reasonable inquiries and clarifications about that information. 

 

 

[Ryan.]

I would not consider an inquiry for more information, whether it be contextualized GPA citations or clearer pictures, to be threadkrapping. 

Inciting, inflammatory or sarcastic comments are threadkraps of the first order. 

[Ryan.]

While on the subject, there seems to be a rise in fuzzy, distant and just plain half azzed pictures of books in the sales forums. 

[DeadOne]

Is the information gathered by GPAnalysis even supposed to be shared the way that it is in sales threads that specifically quote it? It's very possible that I'm wrong, but my understanding of the "terms and conditions" would be that it is not.

From the GPAnalysis website:
(I've highlighted section 3 below where I believe it states it should not)

Quote

 

The following terms and conditions govern your access to and use of the GPA for COMICS (GPA) proprietary directory (the "Materials") and Online Services (the "Online Services"):

1. SCOPE OF LICENSE GRANT

1.1 Single Copy Subscription Access: You ("User") are hereby granted a nonexclusive, nontransferable, limited license ("Subscription Access") to access and use the Materials and Online Services made available to you on this Web site by GPA, for purposes related to research and information gathering. Your right to use this site is personal to you and you may not sub-license, transfer, sell or assign these rights to any third party without our approval. Any attempt to do so will be void. This Subscription Access is a single copy license, and permits an individual subscriber to access and use the Materials and Online Services from one unique computer terminal or PDA of their choice. User agrees to maintain no more than one (1) concurrent online session per subscription purchased, and is therefore prohibited from accessing either the Materials or Online Services via a dual-modem connection (multilink). The User will be able to access the Online Service from one further unique computer terminial or PDA, on a non-concurrent basis. De-authorization of unique computer terminals or PDAs will be allowed on a limited basis per month for the purpose of authorizing use of Online Service from a further computer terminal or PDA (if the user is not able to access the Online Service from their regular computer terminal or PDA). The materials (including directories, lists, names, data, text, graphics, photographs, software, code and scripts) provided on this Web site are copyrighted, and unauthorized use of any of these materials and/or Online Services may violate copyright and/or other laws, including the 'Digital Millennium Copyright Act.' This Subscription Access includes, to the extent permitted by applicable law, the right to obtain a printout of Materials of the Online Services and to create a single printout of Materials via commands of the User Browser application. User shall be responsible for providing, at its own expense, all communications lines, hardware, software, Online Services and other materials and technology necessary for it to access the Materials and/or Online Services. GPA shall have no responsibility for any failure of such items or any failure or limitation of the Internet or other computer hardware or software. Only individual subscribers or those authorized by their subscribing organization may access and use the Materials and/or Online Services. Additional Materials may be added to or withdrawn from the Online Services, and may be otherwise changed without notice.

1.2 Access and Use Restrictions: Except as specifically provided in Section

1.1, User is prohibited from downloading, storing, reproducing, transmitting, displaying, copying, distributing, selling, renting or using the Materials. Except as specifically provided herein, User may not access or use the Materials or Online Services in any fashion that infringes the copyrights or proprietary interests therein. User may not remove or obscure the copyright notice or other notices posted in conjunction with the Materials, nor modify the Materials in any manner. User may not distribute, sublicense, assign or transfer any rights to use the Materials, either in whole or part, to any third party. User may not decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer or otherwise manipulate any software, code, applets, images, photographs, or scripts in order to derive any source code. "Mirroring" or making available any portion of this Web site by another server is strictly prohibited. User may not decompile, disassemble, rent, lease, loan, sell, sublicense, or create derivative works from the Materials. User may not use any network monitoring or discovery software to determine the site architecture, or extract information about usage or users. User may not use any software robot, spider, electronic agent, other automatic device or manual process to monitor or copy this Web Site or the Materials without GPA's prior written permission. User may not use or otherwise export or re-export the Web Site, Materials or Online Services in violation of the export control laws and regulations of the United States of America.

1.3 Passwords: GPA will provide User with the ability to assign one user ID and password to enable User to access certain or all portions of the Materials, depending upon the subscription selected. User shall be solely responsible for the confidentiality and use of such user IDs and passwords. User shall immediately notify GPA if it becomes aware of any loss or theft of a password or any unauthorized use of a password, user ID, or of the Materials. User shall not use any password or other means to attempt to access portions of the Materials or Online Services for which GPA has not issued User a password. GPA may de-activate any password at any time at its sole and unfettered discretion.

2. OWNERSHIP OF PROPRIETARY RIGHTS

The Materials made available by GPA in connection with this Subscription Access, together with all modifications, and revisions thereto and all copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, lists, software, text, images and other intellectual and proprietary rights, title and interest relating thereto, shall at all times be and remain the property of GPA. The provisions of this clause shall survive the termination of this Agreement.

3. CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION

3.1 Definition: "Confidential Information" shall mean any confidential or other proprietary information disclosed by GPA to the User hereunder, including, but not limited to, directories, lists, reports, analysis, pricing, Online Services plans, specifications, manuals, training materials, brochures, software designs and code, user names, passwords, materials, documents, and other business or technical information.

3.2 Restrictions: User agrees (a) not to disclose, directly or indirectly, to any third party any portion of the Confidential Information without the prior written consent of GPA; (b) to take reasonably necessary precautions to protect the confidentiality of the Confidential Information received hereunder and exercise at least the same degree of care in safeguarding the Confidential Information as the User would with its own confidential information; and (c) promptly advise GPA in writing upon learning of any unauthorized use or disclosure of the Confidential Information.

4. DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES, LIMITATION OF LIABILITY AND INDEMNIFICATION

4.1 THE MATERIALS AND ONLINE SERVICES ARE PROVIDED "AS IS," WITH NO WARRANTIES WHATSOEVER. GPA HEREBY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. IN NO EVENT SHALL GPA BE LIABLE, EXCEPT FOR WILLFUL ACTS, FOR ANY DAMAGES TO USER OR ANY OTHER PARTY WHATSOEVER, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, CONSEQUENTIAL, INCIDENTAL OR SPECIAL DAMAGES OR DAMAGES FOR LOST PROFITS OR LOSSES RESULTING FROM BUSINESS INTERRUPTION OR LOSS OF DATA, REGARDLESS OF THE FORM OF ACTION OR LEGAL THEORY UNDER WHICH THE LIABILITY MAY BE ASSERTED, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OR LIKELIHOOD OF SUCH DAMAGES.

4.2 User agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless, GPA, its affiliates, and their respective officers, directors, employees, agents, licensors, representatives, and third party providers to this Web site from and against all losses, expenses, damages and costs, including reasonable attorneys' fees, resulting from any violation of this Agreement by User.

5. TERM

The Initial Term of this Agreement shall be as stated in the Order ("Initial Term"). The Initial Term shall begin upon commencement of Online Services to User, provided, however, no Online Services shall commence unless and until GPA receives and accepts a completed Order from User, plus payment in full for Online Services to be rendered during the Initial Term. GPA reserves the right to reject any submitted Order for any or no reason prior to written acceptance thereof by GPA. After the Initial Term, unless otherwise agreed to by the parties, this Agreement shall automatically renew for successive terms of equal length as the Initial Term unless terminated or cancelled by either party only as provided in Paragraph 6 below. The Initial Term plus all successive renewal periods during which Online Services is provided shall be collectively referred to as the "Term."

6. NOTICE

User may cancel their subscription at any time though the GPA website. It is incumbent upon the User to provide all necessary details when cancelling. Cancellations are effective immediately, however User will be able to access the Materials and Online Services for the remainder of the current billing Term.

7. MISCELLANEOUS

If User breaches any term or condition of this Subscription Access, GPA may, in addition to any other remedies available at law or equity, deny User access to the Materials and Online Services, as well as to any other Web sites owned and/or operated by GPA. In the event that any term or condition of this Subscription Access shall, in whole or in part, be determined to be invalid, unenforceable or void for any reason, such determination shall only affect the portion of such term or condition determined to be invalid, unenforceable or void, and shall not in any way affect the remaining terms and conditions herein. Any waiver, modification, or amendment of any term or condition of this license will be effective only if in writing and signed by GPA and User. These terms and conditions (and any modifications thereto) constitute the entire agreement between GPA and User with regard to the subject matter hereof, and supersede all prior understandings and agreements, whether written or oral, as to such subject matter. Nothing contained in these terms and conditions shall be deemed to constitute either party as the agent or representative of the other party, or both parties as joint ventures or partners for any purpose.

 

 

[Ryan.]

I don't think GPA can consider publically available third party sales data to constitute its own CI.