GRADING CONTEST : ROUND 8

[ArAich]

Um, I was talking about my perception of a scan in the grading contest. Greggy is the one that decided to throw himself into the volcano. But your points are noted.

 

"BTW Doc,

 

I think you need a primer on scanning yourself. Your auction scans are way overexposed (which hides defects) and they look like they were shot through a screen door. Color is pretty mottled too."

 

 

[Red Hook]

Um, I was talking about my perception of a scan in the grading contest. Greggy is the one that decided to throw himself into the volcano. But your points are noted.

 

"BTW Doc,

 

I think you need a primer on scanning yourself. Your auction scans are way overexposed (which hides defects) and they look like they were shot through a screen door. Color is pretty mottled too."

 

 

 

Don't you recognize a scattershot slam when someone's getting torqued? Come on, your a board vet!

 

Anyway, I am seriously done in this thread. There's one with my name on it I have to attend to. (uh, just kidding.)

[ArAich]

The way I see it...CGC is all wrong here...the book is obviously a 9.4 as I had graded it...man...CGC blows...guess it's time to use PGX...

[toro]

The way I see it...CGC is all wrong here...the book is obviously a 9.4 as I had graded it...man...CGC blows...guess it's time to use PGX...

 

PGX grading higher these days?

 

The last book I sent to them came back a 7.5, totally disagreed, sent same book into CGC and came back 8.5.

[Nefaria]

Not knowing what tanning is, beyond the beach babes and all this discussion about it. It would have been nice to reference the book that has caused such controversy. I feel it was taken down too soon IMO