Point Five's 4th Annual Grading Contest: ROUND 3 BOOKS! 5 5

[Nschenks]

Grades in! Pretty sure this is the round where the bottom falls completely out for me...but hey, can't get worse than -3 points! Nice little perk of this scoring system in that even if (read: when) I bomb, it won't look like a little league team bowing out to the mercy rule.

[Flanders82]

Round 1: I hope I'm not in last place

Round 2: I'm getting pretty good at this

Round 3: I have no idea what I'm doing 

Edited June 23, 2023 by Flanders82

[universal soldier]

Grades in 

 

 

 

[Point Five]

10 minutes...   

 

[ADAMANTIUM]

[BriD.]

[Point Five]

CLOSED

Reveals up shortly...

 

[ADAMANTIUM]

[Point Five]

7. Love Diary #31

I thought this was a 2.5/3.0 tweener so was pleased to squeak out the 3.0. Too bad about the PQ (it's certainly a supple book overall) but ah well.
 

[Point Five]

8. Mysterious Adventures #17

I had this as a 5.0 in hand, so I'm surprised / bummed it graded this low. I can see a 4.5 in retrospect due to the creasing on the back and the spine issues, but 4.0 seems a touch... uncharitable. Presents more like a midgrade.
 

[ADAMANTIUM]

Wow I did pretty good

Duh don dom

[Point Five]

9. Mystery Men #2

I guessed this one as a 3.0, so verrrry happy about this outcome. Definitely an 'early GA bump' working for me here. Y'all were way harsh on this one, with most guesses somewhere in the 2s.

 

[ADAMANTIUM]

There it is!

 

[ADAMANTIUM]

For the record

3.5

4.0

2.0

So another 

 

[Flanders82]

Definitely different graders on the Hawkman and Mysterious Adventures. 

[Mars76]

7. Love Diary #31    3.0

8. Mysterious Adventures #17    5.0

9. Mystery Men #2    2.0

This was not my round

[scburdet]

I literally waffled back and forth about 3.0/3.5 on #7 & & #9. And got them backwards.

[scburdet]

On 6/22/2023 at 11:04 PM, Point Five said:

I had this as a 5.0 in hand

I agree since I guessed 5.0

[Sandflea]

7. Love Diary #31 - 1.8

8. Mysterious Adventures #17 - 4.5

9. Mystery Men #2 - 2.5

[universal soldier]

At leasrt I was in the ballpark this time. One grade off on each. Hopefully out of the basement this time