Guess the CGC grade: last round?

[WOXL]

Alrighty... first time trying this.

 

The only things I can detect wrong with the 86 are rounded corners, a slight spine crease next to Spidey's arm in the price/issue do-hickey, and a little smudge on the back near the spine halfway down. The cover is also off center with a tilted white band near the spine, but CGC doesn't knock points off for that, right? I'll go 9.4

 

On the 135, I notice some spine creases, blunted lower right corner, and scanner schmutz. How about a 9.0

 

-Bob

[osborn_fr]

9.4 & 9.2

[mar-vell]

9.0

9.2

[Carnage]

What's the answer?

[namisgr]

Sorry for the delay in getting the "answer" scans posted, but they'll be up later today - damn job...

 

Anywhoo, only a single forumite has posted the correct answer for the two books, so feel free to take more shots until I get the scans posted.

[joeypost]

9.2

9.0

[-cryptkeeper-]

9.4

9.0

[burntboy]

both look pretty sweet to me - around 9.2's each.....................

[Psiknight]

9.4

9.2

[Genesis Comics]

What's the answer???

[sterlingcomics]

9.0 and 9.2

[burntboy]

since this is still going on, i'm revising my guess to 9.2 and 9.4.................

 

although i have a hard time believing the second book is nicer..............

[SuperBird]

9.2, 9.0

[Darrell F]

I give both of them a 9.0

[burntboy]

hey bob - you ever coming back to end the suspense???

[Carnage]

grrrrrrrrrrrrr

[Aces]

His dog ate the scans...

[ComicsAndCode]

The back covers look nearly perfect...is that from the scan?

 

ASM 86 9.2

 

ASM 135 8.5

 

And we trying to match against CGC grade or your's?

[ComicsAndCode]

I had a 135 that was CGCed at 8.0. Looked very similar to your's.

[Genesis Comics]

So..............