GRADING CONTEST : Round 5

[deathlok]

Ooooh, I think I guessed 9.0 on this one.

Maybe not.

[shiverbones]

I took 8.5 on it. the back edge looked to bad to me

[Norrin_Radd]

Whoops!

 

I probably would've graded it 9.4 anyways.

[DeeDee-migration]

finally got one right!!!!!!

[Karma23]

i said 9.4 cuz of this mysterious 'Nik Bump' I keep hearing about

[Paladin]

Whoops!

 

I probably would've graded it 9.4 anyways.

 

That's what I did.

 

Ruined my mini-streak of 2! Time to get back on track!

[kc120us]

finally got one right!!!!!!

 

Congrats, I missed it by .2

[shiverbones]

don't you score 2 points if its a 9.0 & you guess 8.5

[THE_BEYONDER]

SHOOT!! I think I was in the 9.2 crowd! :\ At least another notch woo! I really hope I didn't do the PLOD on this, it was tempting for some reason.

 

I went 9.2....and came very close to pulling the trigger on a PLOD call as well. Something about the purples when you stare at the book too long....

[Aces]

7.0 - 1

 

7.5 - 2

 

8.0 - 1

 

8.5 - 8

 

9.0 - 25

 

9.2 - 24

 

9.4 - 26

 

9.6 - 6

 

Awe Geez...

I went with 9.4 cause that last POS got a 9.2 and this one was way better.

 

Don't 9.4s get 1 point?

[JuliusSeizure]

Score!!!

[blutobc]

Argh! One off again!!!

 

Me too, flipped a coin.. 9.0...9.2, I went with 9.2

 

I also thought the book was trimmed and wasted my PLOD points, so

I am not sure if Congrats are in order Nik...

 

I will take my points and slink away till the next round

 

Ze-

 

I missed the grade...and also came very close to guessing PLOD for possible right edge trimming too. At least this time everyone pretty much agreed on a 9.0.-9.4 range.

[Sid]

SHOOT!! I think I was in the 9.2 crowd! :\ At least another notch woo! I really hope I didn't do the PLOD on this, it was tempting for some reason.

 

I went 9.2....and came very close to pulling the trigger on a PLOD call as well. Something about the purples when you stare at the book too long....

 

I hadn't thought of that.

[Owls Head]

SHOOT!! I think I was in the 9.2 crowd! :\ At least another notch woo! I really hope I didn't do the PLOD on this, it was tempting for some reason.

 

I went 9.2....and came very close to pulling the trigger on a PLOD call as well. Something about the purples when you stare at the book too long....

 

 

 

yeah... don't do that... stare at the purples to long....

[Karma23]

7.0 - 1

 

7.5 - 2

 

8.0 - 1

 

8.5 - 8

 

9.0 - 25

 

9.2 - 24

 

9.4 - 26

 

9.6 - 6

 

Awe Geez...

I went with 9.4 cause that last POS got a 9.2 and this one was way better.

 

Don't 9.4s get 1 point?

that's what i thought

[Sid]

4 baby \o/ moving on up!

[Warlord]

SHOOT!! I think I was in the 9.2 crowd! :\ At least another notch woo! I really hope I didn't do the PLOD on this, it was tempting for some reason.

 

The blotchy black area at the top left right near a couple spine bends was really tempting me to peg this as the PLOD, but I finally decided to pass on making that call. Whew!

[nik]

Ooooh, I think I guessed 9.0 on this one.

Maybe not.

 

No one else guessed what you guessed and you did not guess 7.0

[Sid]

SHOOT!! I think I was in the 9.2 crowd! :\ At least another notch woo! I really hope I didn't do the PLOD on this, it was tempting for some reason.

 

The blotchy black area at the top left right near a couple spine bends was really tempting me to peg this as the PLOD, but I finally decided to pass on making that call. Whew!

 

that was it, that black spot. I googled the cover to make sure it existed on other ones I think that's why I didn't call it.

[Timmay]

 

also there were 8 who took a shot and guessed PLOD. Congrats to those 8 as they are all wrong