The economics of this factor into play. CGC makes easy money off of moderns, big money off of big dollar submissions, and good money off of press/resub books. The books that take the most time and effort to grade and yield the least profit are those similar to what you submitted. Despite what we'd all like to think, CGC isn't vested financially in making us neurotic obscure GA collectors happy. If they were to concede on this, a precedent would be set where all of our OCD-like demands would be fair game going forward. That would take time away from making good money. My advice: keep your books raw and document them in a spreadsheet as you see fit