1.0 or 3.0 or 5.0...should be the same list
action 1
detective 27
superman 1
batman 1
captain America 1
marvel 1
all star 8
action 7
detective 31
whiz 1
an argument could be made to replace whiz 1 with pep 22...6 one way, half a dozen the other...with shazam picking up steam, went that route
I'd say whiz 1 and all star 8 will surpass marvel 1
Personally, I would take the Pep 22 over the AS 8 and the 'Tec 31 since it is a much tougher book to come across.
Especially when there appears to be so many copies of "rec 31 that has come into the marketplace over the past couple of years. I believe the significance of the AS 8 is diluted a bit by the presence of both Sensation 1 and WW 1.
But that's just my rationale for taking Pep 22 over both AS 8 and 'Tec 31.
Nothing wrong with that preference. The market prefers batman and ww to Archie , hence my positions. But many books are interchangeable , your mileage will vary