So this is interesting; at least nothing I've had happen before...
I received a notification that a user named JKirbyFan had tried to register my copy of Rocekteer: Special edition. I hit the "reject" button which takes you to a form on the CGC site that asks you to fill out a short message. Unfortunately, the page is also very poorly designed in that when you are done typing your message, the buttons are labelled "accept" and "reject". Assuming I needed to "accept" the form I just entered, that's the button I hit.
Doh. Turns out that button "Accept"s the transfer.
So I promptly re-registered the comic back to myself. Within 20 minutes, I received a response from JKirbyFan saying "the book has been paid for and is mine." and the transfer rejected.
So I sent him a board message stating that I think he had been duped or made a mistake and sent a scan of the book in question with it.
This was on the 2nd. He has read the message, but no response. Now I'm suspicious that he's just sniping books.
I emailed CGC, but as usual, they are slow to respond too...
Anyone have any ideas?