It the buyer did not mistake what he was buying.....that's crazy! Glad I have #1-110, I would hate spending big money on reprints.
You need not worry. You own everything.
This book guides for about 4 bucks in the current Overstreet. I could see it going for double to triple Guide in VF because of movie mayhem...but over 20 times Guide?
What movie mayhem? Also, "guide" is outdated the minute it's published. I love shops that go by Overstreet.
Even negative publicity is publicity, re: the movie exposure.
I used the guide as a guide, as a baseline. I didn't make grand claims for it...but at the same time, I think it can't be so easily thrown under the bus, as many in the Internet age would have it.
As for the love you have for shops going by Overstreet, is it a selective love? What about when it's, say, full Guide for 3rd tier title, mid-grade Bronze? You love that, right?
Yes, the do say there is no bad publicity, but a bad movie doesn't not draw people to buy those comics.
If I know a shop uses Overstreet, I know there are plenty of books to hunt that have increased recently in value.