I disagree. I don't think it has anything to do with the books.
There is honest confusion and then there is willful ignorance.
I believe this guy was honestly confused and not willfully ignorant (or disobedient).
I haven't followed this new thread that closely but the guy is learning the rules and adapting as he goes along. He's also being apologetic, even though there was initially a bit of an uproar on both sides.
He's not selling through another dealer, he is allowing a dealer to act as an escrow.
He's answering PMs, and adapting as he learns.
Part of the problem that the thread has experienced seems to be an overreaction from some board members from the beginning of the thread causing a mess, as is usually the case when people just fire first and think later.
It's unrealistic to expect everyone to fit in immediately from the get-go. It takes a while for people to get their wings and fit in.
I was harassed as a PGX shill when I first started posting here.