- Popular Post
-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
-
Posts
4,982 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Posts posted by Badger
-
-
-
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
- Tom789, Marty Mann, jimjum12 and 5 others
- 8
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
-
On 2/4/2024 at 4:05 PM, wombat said:
I don't think what CGC does fits any definition of mass production.
They take a raw product, process it, encapsulate it, and then ship it out mainly to retailers who sell for a large markup compared to the raw goods. Pretty much the textbook definition of mass production.
-
On 2/15/2024 at 11:31 AM, Number 6 said:
The issue I have with the "new case" solution (and I'm not directing this at you personally, just using you statement as a jumping off point to vent my frustration) is that: what about the thousands of comics in the compromised 3rd gen cases?
If you're holding any of those...which a lot of us are...your options are to either reward CGC for their gross negligence but paying them their reholder fee to have all those books put into (what we hope is) a new, tamper-proof holder (and hope that CGC doesn't manage to screw that up by being asleep at the wheel again)....otherwise you're stuck with your books (for which you already paid CGC their fee for encapsulation or paid the CGC tax when you bought it) now automatically view as suspect and compromised just by virtue of the case they happen to be in, and would probably have to sell at a discount if at all.
No matter what CGC does, it's hard for me to feel good about anything CGC going forward, and unfortunately the CGC cabal has their tentacles so thoroughly entrenched in this hobby there's no going back.
I agree. My solution just fixes(?) the going forward part. All of us with substantial investments in CGC product are possibly left with devalued goods. The only good news is that if the Ewert micro-trimming fiasco didn't tank professionally graded comics I do not think this will either. Even with a possible 2,000 books impacted that leaves, what, another 2,000,000 that are fine? Nothing to see here, folks.
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
On 2/15/2024 at 10:05 AM, szav said:Step one- publicly announce that they will subject themselves to external independent audit of their quality processes, security vulnerabilities, etc by a reputable organization. Commit to making changes and further future such audits.
Step Two - take much needed steps to vastly increase the difficulty of counterfeiting their product. Think the sorts of things you see on currency. Embedded into the plastic mold magnetic strips or colorful wispy threads, hard if not impossible to replicate, and easy to visually verify unique features on each individual slab.
They should invest in meeting ISO 9001:2015 standards along with yet another case redesign. If they can state that they are audited yearly and meet ISO 9001:2015 standards AND that they have implemented new fraud protections it would give them a new lease on life. It would give the collector community a solid date they can reference as in, "This book was encapsulated before June,2024 so I know it could have been swapped. This book was encapsulated after 2024 so, with CGC's process and case changes, I feel comfortable believing that the product is as represented."
-
On 2/12/2024 at 1:52 PM, makis said:
These are some nice comics! i think that whiz comics have many undervalued covers.
im 33y, not too young not too old!as a collector im one year old,i start to collect some modern age bookes, like ultimate fallout 4, but i found that golden age era is for me.
i hope to live enough, so i have the chance to get some of my favourite covers. at least the ones that are still in reach...my only regret is that i didnt discover this amazing hobby earlier.
33 is a fantastic age to start and I agree, Whiz is a very underrated title.
-
- Marty Mann and adamstrange
- 1
- 1
-
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
On 2/12/2024 at 10:58 AM, makis said:You have excellent taste in comics! Welcome and I'm looking forward to seeing more of your collection. I'm 55 years old and we have people here from 18 and into their late 80s. If you don't mind sharing, how old are you? GA collectors tend towards the older ages if only due to the cost of GA. It's easier to afford later in life it seems. but for most, never easy!
Here are a few representative books of my favorites
- makis, Mmehdy, Ltpink2002 and 2 others
- 5
-
-
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
-
-
Red to Red
- sagii and Frisco Larson
- 2
-
Orange to Red
-
-
-
-
-
Why are people getting bent out of shape over CGC asking for a receipt? Can anyone tell me an example of receiving a refund, from someone who did not sell the item in question, without being asked for a receipt? Seriously, it is the start of the refund conversation/dance. If you have a swapped 9.8 ASM #194, is CGC just supposed to send you a check for the last 90 day GPA average which is $2716? What if you are one of the poor souls who paid above $5,000 for your copy? How would CGC know this without a receipt?
Take a deep breath, settle your butt down in your sofa, deep breath, and explain you do not have a receipt but you bought the book from X for this much money at this auction, convention, or back alley. I have confidence that CGC will make you whole. They want this whole incident to fade into memory like the Ewert scandal. The best way to do this is to get the impacted people paid and hushed.
A better question would be that if you want your book back, how would CGC return it? Obviously they would have to return it but it has been broken out of the original holder for inspection. I feel they should grade it for free and offer to return it properly encased and graded. Would they do that or would they just send you your raw comic?
- comeaux and VintageComics
- 1
- 1
-
- Mr. Lady Luck and Robot Man
- 2
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
CGC Files Lawsuit Against Employees
in Comics General
Posted
Mass production means "without serial numbers" is the definition you are touting? I'll give you a minute to think that through.
How many serialized Ford Mustangs are mass produced each year? Roughly 50,000. Does CGC produce more serialized slabbed comics? Yes. As to your focusing on division and specialization of human labor, well, in this case, it is the graders that are separated from the restoration expert, which is separated, from QA, and then packaging and shipping. Mustangs are largely built by robot. Does this mean they are no longer mass produced? Of course not. If the doors were still attached by a human, who had to attach a minimum of 40 doors a day, would that suddenly become custom craftmanship? No. it would not.
Mass production is an assembly of parts into a finished product using specialization of labor and tools. Lamborghini, where they can produce a few cars a month, is custom craftmanship. CGC is mass production and that is why the head scratching production errors occur. How can a comic be sealed into a case wall without anyone noticing? Mass Production. This is not a bunch of people lovingly examining your most prized collectible. This is a bunch of labor focused on turning out as much product, sealed and graded comic books, as possible.
Seriously, it would be impossible for CGC to churn out as many slabs as they do in a year if they were not using principles of mass production. How is this even an argument?