• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

scburdet

Member
  • Posts

    5,427
  • Joined

Everything posted by scburdet

  1. 6.5/7.0. Maybe a grade higher b/c CGC has been more lenient with spine tics. The back cover is remarkably clean.
  2. 6.5/7.0. I'm inclined to go higher b/c I believe in the Spider-Man bump
  3. Just happened to pull this one out & realized it's actually kind of nice. Small bindery tear on the TL corner.
  4. I don't see much that can be cleaned, but C&P is typically a package deal & this needs pressed to remove the roll. Pretty sharp looking front cover. Maybe not the prettiest around the spine/staples, but not much wear. The browning around the edges is going to hurt what could otherwise have been an ≥8.0 candidate. The darkening is enough to drop it into 6.5/7.0 range.
  5. Any notes? I'd like to see if the graders picked up on any of the little blemishes I was seeing around the staples & the one scuff? mid spine. Admittedly, I thought the pages looked a little darker than OW. I have this in an 8.0 too. I'd say the front cover on mine is a tad better, but it has a spot of some kind on the back, which we all know is a CGC no-no.
  6. 5.5/6.0. I would think the higher possibility hinges on how much the grader hates the corner chip
  7. Pressable to 7.0 I'll wager. I agree that the current market for this book grading would be a break even proposition at best.
  8. There's a Grading & Restoration Issues forum In this forum:
  9. 2.5/3.0. I can see this as classic "comes in with a higher grade than people think" book.
  10. Al Milgrom, Garth Ennis, Ron Marz/Greg Land, Amanda Conner, Don Rosa, Jimmy Palmiotti, John Giang & Ron Wilson
  11. Walt Simonson, Jim Starlin, Louise Simonson & Al Milgrom