which one would you choose, and why ???

[showcase4]

Both sold within the past 60 days for an averaged price of approx. $24,500. Which one would you choose, and why ?

[seanfingh]

 

The Cap 1. TOS 39 is at the absolute apex of movie hype. It will always be a key great book, but this is so close to the top of the market; why buy now. That Cap 1 is super solid.

[Dollarbill]

The Cap 1. TOS 39 is at the absolute apex of movie hype. It will always be a key great book, but this is so close to the top of the market; why buy now. That Cap 1 is super solid.

I would have to agree.Well the TOS is nice and I would love to own it.You cant go wrong with a Cap 1.

[tsarax]

The Cap 1. TOS 39 is at the absolute apex of movie hype. It will always be a key great book, but this is so close to the top of the market; why buy now. That Cap 1 is super solid.

I would have to agree.Well the TOS is nice and I would love to own it.You cant go wrong with a Cap 1.

 

AGREED! Not even a tough decision for me.

[nik]

Neither one

[seanfingh]

Neither one

 

[arexcrooke]

 

Tough call. Do I take the HG ToS at movie hype prices, or the iconic Cap in mid-grade.

 

Ill pull a Bedrock, and on both of them.

 

Cause I really dont know tbh

[arexcrooke]

Neither one

Why Nik?

[nik]

TOS = lame azz cover

 

Cap = not HG enough

[arexcrooke]

You really dont like the ToS cover? Its one of my more fav of the early Marvels. Just something about it.

[nik]

Cant stand it. Only thing that book has going for it is value.

[CAP Freak]

Captain America 1 for sure!

[batman_fan]

Captain America 1 even with the cruddy eraser marks. Look for all Ironman books going the same way as Daredevil books.

[MrBedrock]

Neither one

(thumbs u

[piper]

Cap 1.

 

The TOS 39's price will start to drop now that the movie hype is done.

[thehumantorch]

Cap 1 by a mile. Iconic Hitler cover.

[rjpb]

Never been an IM fan - though I liked the movie, but that is a weak 6.5 on the Cap - so I'm with Nik - neither.

[Aman619]

TOS39 for me. A high grade first appearance of a movie star vs a low grade first appearance of a lesser in demand superhero? Easy choice. dont forget that Iron Man movie was a hit, with a sequel on the way, so the pre-release price hike will not fade away like Punisher or Daredevil.

[EastCoastExchange-migratio]

TOS39

[tth2]

dont forget that Iron Man movie was a hit, with a sequel on the way, so the pre-release price hike will not fade away like Punisher or Daredevil.

Yeah, I don`t understand all the people equating IM with DD. IM has serious legs as a movie and and outperformed all expectations. But for Indiana Jones, it could very well have ended up as the top grossing movie of the year. Maybe wishful thinking on the part of those who missed the chance to pick up IM appearances at cheaper prices.