More practice--guess the grade on this Showcase 34

[JohnT]

I know, it's tough to look through plastic, but give it your best shot!

 

 

[pennynike1]

Nice book. I am going to go with an 8.0.

[topofthetotem]

6.5

[pennynike1]

What did I miss? The spine looks quite nice.

[topofthetotem]

Corner crease and what looks like staining on the top BCC.

[pennynike1]

I have seen worse corner creases get an 8.0 from CGC, however, I do see your point about the staining on the back. I missed that, as I was focusing more on the front cover. Due to the assist, I hereby amend my 8.0 grade to 7.0

 

 

[mysterymachine]

I agree with totem. 6.5. There's some hard to see wear on the front cover. Look above the M for example.

[pennynike1]

I agree with totem. 6.5. There's some hard to see wear on the front cover. Look above the M for example.

 

7.0

[joeypost]

Light wear on cover and spine. Blunting on 3 corners. 2 small color breaking creases and stains on the BC.

 

I give it 5.5/6.0. The CGC grade I imagine is 6.0

[JohnT]

I agree with totem. 6.5. There's some hard to see wear on the front cover. Look above the M for example.

 

The "slash" above the M is on the plastic...luckily! Hadn't noticed that before. Scans really do bring out every little detail...

[sterlingcomics]

I don't know if this practice is making me more or less confident.

 

FN 6.0

[backtomarvel]

Was this book submitted by Nik

 

I'll say 6.0, although if I had it in hand I may push it down a bit if that crease in the URFC (that's a color-breaking crease, right?) looks worse than in the scan.

 

In the end ... 6.0

[nochips]

6.0

[JohnT]

I'll give the grade in a couple of hours...

[pennynike1]

OK John, it is time to reveal...

[JohnT]

People got pretty locked in on this one. The grade is...

 

6.0.

 

Good job to everyone who got it right!

[burntboy]

People got pretty locked in on this one. The grade is...

 

6.0.

 

Good job to everyone who got it right!

 

That is one PRETTY 6.0 in my book.............. (thumbs u

 

I'm thinking the yellowish tint on top of both covers could have been the books downfall, because otherwise it appears nicer than that.............

[joeypost]

People got pretty locked in on this one. The grade is...

 

6.0.

 

Good job to everyone who got it right!

 

Light wear on cover and spine. Blunting on 3 corners. 2 small color breaking creases and stains on the BC.

 

I give it 5.5/6.0. The CGC grade I imagine is 6.0

 

 

Why can't I be this acurate on Niks books