• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

SET EXPANSION REQUESTS (existing sets only)

Started by Gemma,

2,533 posts in this topic

JMoses

JMoses

Posted
Posted
Foreign comics have no place listed inside domestic comic registries. :sumo:

 

Very annoying.

 

While I still love and appreciate foreign comics, they should be grouped in separate, special sets.

 

I don't even collect Spider-man, but the Argentinian Edition? Give me a break.

 

There are already too many superfluous additions being made to existing sets. I think people are starting to use set additions as a backhanded tactic to play the points game. If some obscure slot can be added, JUST because I'm the only one with a graded copy and I want to gain points and I want to :censored: the competition...

 

I just don't think that's right, especially when it makes the set look random and ugly.

 

 

+1

 

There are various foreign editions of Chew which should never make the Chew set.

 

 

+1 more -- there are hundreds and hundreds of foreign language versions of Superman dating back almost 75 years. Please let's keep that Pandora's box closed. However, I think a "Foreign Versions" set of whatever titles people wanted to build would be fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
solarcadet

solarcadet

Posted
Posted
Foreign comics have no place listed inside domestic comic registries. :sumo:

 

Very annoying.

 

While I still love and appreciate foreign comics, they should be grouped in separate, special sets.

 

I don't even collect Spider-man, but the Argentinian Edition? Give me a break.

 

There are already too many superfluous additions being made to existing sets. I think people are starting to use set additions as a backhanded tactic to play the points game. If some obscure slot can be added, JUST because I'm the only one with a graded copy and I want to gain points and I want to :censored: the competition...

 

I just don't think that's right, especially when it makes the set look random and ugly.

 

 

+1

 

There are various foreign editions of Chew which should never make the Chew set.

 

 

+1 more -- there are hundreds and hundreds of foreign language versions of Superman dating back almost 75 years. Please let's keep that Pandora's box closed. However, I think a "Foreign Versions" set of whatever titles people wanted to build would be fine.

 

not hundreds and hundreds...from my research less than 30 language versions

 

I wish you were right i would buy them :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
JMoses

JMoses

Posted
Posted
Foreign comics have no place listed inside domestic comic registries. :sumo:

 

Very annoying.

 

While I still love and appreciate foreign comics, they should be grouped in separate, special sets.

 

I don't even collect Spider-man, but the Argentinian Edition? Give me a break.

 

There are already too many superfluous additions being made to existing sets. I think people are starting to use set additions as a backhanded tactic to play the points game. If some obscure slot can be added, JUST because I'm the only one with a graded copy and I want to gain points and I want to :censored: the competition...

 

I just don't think that's right, especially when it makes the set look random and ugly.

 

 

+1

 

There are various foreign editions of Chew which should never make the Chew set.

 

 

+1 more -- there are hundreds and hundreds of foreign language versions of Superman dating back almost 75 years. Please let's keep that Pandora's box closed. However, I think a "Foreign Versions" set of whatever titles people wanted to build would be fine.

 

not hundreds and hundreds...from my research less than 30 language versions

 

I wish you were right i would buy them :)

 

I should have been clearer -- several different languages, but hundreds of foreign language issues out there to clutter up existing sets. Just the famous Superman 233 alone

 

(source, which includes pictures: http://collectingsuperman.com/?p=1906):

 

Title & Issue Number (if applicable) Country or Language

 

Superman #233 United States

Superman #233 Millenium Edition United States

Superman #5 Geant France

Superman La Courbe du Temps France

Superman Nembokid #3 Cenisio Italy

Superman #137 Heritage Belgium and Canada (French)

Superman #858 Novaro Mexico

Superman En Los Setentas Mexico

Superman Batman #8 Germany

Superman Museum Version 1 Germany

Superman Museum Version 2 Germany

Stålmannen #4 Semic Sweden

Supermann #4 Semic Norway

Teräsmies #4 Finland

Superman Bi #72 EBAL Brazil

Superman Classics #97 Dutch

Superman #2 1978 Series Japan

Supermann Special Edition Japan

Superman Supacomic #150 Australia

 

I completely respect those who collect these versions, but they are very much a separate thing from the original sets, and not mere variants.

 

Just my take . . .

Link to comment
Share on other sites
solarcadet

solarcadet

Posted
Posted
Foreign comics have no place listed inside domestic comic registries. :sumo:

 

Very annoying.

 

While I still love and appreciate foreign comics, they should be grouped in separate, special sets.

 

I don't even collect Spider-man, but the Argentinian Edition? Give me a break.

 

There are already too many superfluous additions being made to existing sets. I think people are starting to use set additions as a backhanded tactic to play the points game. If some obscure slot can be added, JUST because I'm the only one with a graded copy and I want to gain points and I want to :censored: the competition...

 

I just don't think that's right, especially when it makes the set look random and ugly.

 

 

+1

 

There are various foreign editions of Chew which should never make the Chew set.

 

 

+1 more -- there are hundreds and hundreds of foreign language versions of Superman dating back almost 75 years. Please let's keep that Pandora's box closed. However, I think a "Foreign Versions" set of whatever titles people wanted to build would be fine.

 

not hundreds and hundreds...from my research less than 30 language versions

 

I wish you were right i would buy them :)

 

I should have been clearer -- several different languages, but hundreds of foreign language issues out there to clutter up existing sets. Just the famous Superman 233 alone

 

(source, which includes pictures: http://collectingsuperman.com/?p=1906):

 

Title & Issue Number (if applicable) Country or Language

 

Superman #233 United States

Superman #233 Millenium Edition United States

Superman #5 Geant France

Superman La Courbe du Temps France

Superman Nembokid #3 Cenisio Italy

Superman #137 Heritage Belgium and Canada (French)

Superman #858 Novaro Mexico

Superman En Los Setentas Mexico

Superman Batman #8 Germany

Superman Museum Version 1 Germany

Superman Museum Version 2 Germany

Stålmannen #4 Semic Sweden

Supermann #4 Semic Norway

Teräsmies #4 Finland

Superman Bi #72 EBAL Brazil

Superman Classics #97 Dutch

Superman #2 1978 Series Japan

Supermann Special Edition Japan

Superman Supacomic #150 Australia

 

I completely respect those who collect these versions, but they are very much a separate thing from the original sets, and not mere variants.

 

Just my take . . .

 

i agree with you. You make a good point the registry should be separate in foreign and original (domestic)

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest

Guest

Posted
Posted
Now that Locke and Key has come to its end can we get the completed list of books in listed.

 

Thanks,

 

Matjo

 

 

Be more specific on which books and titles you would like listed.

 

Thanks,

 

Nicole

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Matjo

Matjo

Posted
Posted
Now that Locke and Key has come to its end can we get the completed list of books in listed.

 

Thanks,

 

Matjo

 

 

Be more specific on which books and titles you would like listed.

 

Thanks,

 

Nicole

 

---

Locke & Key: Clockworks

1 1st 6/11

1 RI 6/11

1 RI (Signed) 6/11

1 Jetpack Variant 6/11

2 1st 8/11

2 RI 8/11

3 1st 10/11

3 RI 10/11

4 1st 1/12

4 RI 1/12

5 1st 3/12

5 RI 3/12

6 1st 4/12

6 RI 4/12

 

Locke & Key: Guide to the Known Keys

nn 1st 10/11

nn RI 10/11

nn Comic Market 10/11

nn Convention Edition 1/12

 

Locke & Key: Grindhouse

nn 1st 8/12

nn RI (Signed) 8/12

nn Jetpack Variant 8/12

nn 2nd 11/12

 

Locke & Key: Omega

1 1st 11/12

1 RI 11/12

1 SUB CVR 11/12

1 Jetpack Variant 11/12

2 1st 12/12

2 RI 12/12

3 1st 2/13

3 RI 2/13

4 1st 4/13

4 RI 4/13

5 1st 6/13

5 RI 6/13

 

L & K: Welcome to Lovecraft 100 Penny Press Edition

1 1st 9/13

 

Locke & Key: Alpha

1 1st 9/13

1 RI 9/13

2 1st 12/13 Cover A Gabriel Rodriguez

2 1st 12/13 Cover B Simon Bisley

2 1st 12/13 Cover C Glenn Fabry

2 1st 12/13 Cover D Michael Kaluta

2 1st 12/13 Cover E Bill Sienkiewicz

2 1st 12/13 Cover F Dave Sim

2 1st 12/13 Cover G Bernie Wrightson

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bagofleas

bagofleas

Posted
Posted

Ok. I promise not to bother you again after this one. At least for today. :)

 

Never mind on the Critical Mass #5. It is on there as Shadowline Saga #5.

 

And also add Shadowman #1 (2012) Sienkiewicz Variant Cover

 

You are awesome!! Thank You!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ronnylama

Ronnylama

Posted
Posted

Hello Nicole. I have a few Bill Sienkiewicz covers to add. Shadow #1 and #6 DC 1987 I believe he did more but will check.

Wolverine #145 Nabisco Variant

Hit-Girl #5 Sienk variant my cert # is 0213030009

Daredevil End of Days variant #8

Batman Cacophony #2 cert # 0213030008 It says Kubert cover but it is most definitely a Sienk cover

That is it for now

 

Can I get the points on the 3 books in the set. I believe they are the only books CGC so they show a ZERO.......

I am a pain tonight....look forward to seeing you at ECCC

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest

Guest

Posted
Posted
Hello,

 

I noticed that Showcase # 59 in CGC 9.4 has two different scores. Under the registry "Showcase" that the score is 975 while under "Teen Titans" the score is 540.

 

Can this be corrected?

 

oceanbert

 

This needs to be posted at the Scored to be fixed thread.

 

Thanks,

 

Nicole

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest

Guest

Posted
Posted
Hi again, Nicole! Actually, go ahead and add all six issues of Shadow (1987). He did do them all.

 

Also add Teen Titans Spotlight #10.

And The Question #1-19 and #21-23 and Annual 1

 

I apologize as well for being a pain. :)

 

I just wish I would have had the "Complete" list when making this set. It is a lot easier to add a complete set then to take the time and score out/add each individual comic....at this quantity... just an FYI.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bagofleas

bagofleas

Posted
Posted

Sorry Nicole. I actually had the Question issues on the list. Don't know why they were left off.

 

He did so many covers. A lot of the add ons are recent releases.

 

He also did these four:

 

Hypernaturals #1 1:100 Virgin Variant cover

Hypernaturals #2 1:30 Virgin Variant cover

Hypernaturals #3 1:30 Virgin Variant cover

Hypernaturals #4 1:30 Virgin Variant cover

 

I hate making you have to work harder than you already are. I can't speak for everyone, but you definitely have my complete appreciation for everything you do for us!

 

Thank you so much!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
JMoses

JMoses

Posted
Posted
Ladies:

 

Regarding the Superman One-Shots:

 

Please add JSA Kingdom Come Special: Superman 1

 

Please delete Superman: Peace on Earth 1 -- turns out to be a Treasury-sized comic and therefore unslabbable (is that a word?).

 

Thank You both!

 

This appears to have been skipped, as set adjustment requests made previous to this one have already been done. Thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing