• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

1930's Original Owner Collection Auction, Detective, Tip Top, Funny Pages + more

Started by lhcomics,

167 posts in this topic

Old Fashion PB and J

Old Fashion PB and J

Posted
Posted
I actually think the grading seems pretty loose on all the books except the Daring Mystery. It may be time to submit some stuff if this is an indication of the grading standards today.
I tried to look at this stuff. It just gave me a headache. But the grading so far seems, well... You know that girl in school who just never seemed to say no? Kinda like that.

 

Some nice books though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bunky Brian

Bunky Brian

Posted
Posted
Detective Comics 7 9/37 D.C. Comics Universal 5.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

 

 

det7.jpg

 

I'm excited to see how nicely these books graded out. But am I the only one who is surprised by the 5.5 grade on the Tec #7? Did CGC overlook the large piece that is missing from the middle of the cover?

 

Helllllo? now that RHG has decided to come out of his ivory tower and 2c. I agree, all the grades look high to me, especially this one!! My rough grades are way off, guess I need a class in CGC grading specifications.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Primetime

Primetime

Posted
Posted
Detective Comics 7 9/37 D.C. Comics Universal 5.5 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

 

 

det7.jpg

 

I'm excited to see how nicely these books graded out. But am I the only one who is surprised by the 5.5 grade on the Tec #7? Did CGC overlook the large piece that is missing from the middle of the cover?

 

Helllllo? now that RHG has decided to come out of his ivory tower and 2c. I agree, all the grades look high to me, especially this one!! My rough grades are way off, guess I need a class in CGC grading specifications.

 

where is the Gator? lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites
G.A.tor

G.A.tor

Posted
Posted

does it take a while for your bids to show up?

I bid on a couple of books, confirmed, refreshed, and it still shows previous bid amount and previous (assuming their proxy was less than mine) high bidder (shrug)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
lhcomics

lhcomics

Posted
  • Author
Posted
What did the Tec 14 grade out at? (shrug)

 

The Detectives 12 and 14 were not sent to CGC. If you look at the auction website you can see a link to the "Auction Comic List" this file will show the grades I gave the comics that were not sent to CGC.

 

Auction Comic List DOC

 

***I don't guarantee these grade as the comics are out of my possession***

 

The Auctioneer understands that these comics should be handled as little as possible so if you plan on bidding on a high $ comic that is not CGC'ed it's best to be at the auction.

 

He did not tell me that he had the FF #211 so I did not get to view that comic. (worship)

 

LOT # NAME VOLUME NO. DATE Grade

ALL COMICS ARE CATEGORY AS UNIVERSAL

4 Detective Comics No.11 Jan. 1938 CGC grade (7.0) cr/ow

5 Detective Comics No.13 Mar. 1938 CGC grade (5.5) cr/ow

6 Detective Comics No.9 Nov. 1937 CGC grade (5.0) ow

7 Detective Comics No.12 Feb. 1938 G+ (2.5) cr/ow

8 Detective Comics No.8 Oct. 1937 CGC grade (6.0) cr/ow

9 Tracy Meets the Blank V.1 1939 G/VG (3.5) cr/ow

10 Tracy Gets His Man V. 4 1939 VG (4.0) cream

11a Tracy & The Famon Boys HC Feature book #9 May. 1937 FA/G (1.5) cream brittle edges

11B Star Ranger No.9 Jan.1938 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

12 Detective Comics (Batman)nc No.35 Dec.1939

13 Planet Comics V.1 No.2 Feb. 1940 VG (4.0) cr/ow

14 New Adventure Comics No. 23 Jan. 1938 VG + (4.5) cr/ow

15 New Adventure Comics No.19 Sep. 1937 G (2.0) cr/ow

16 King Comics No.18 Sept. 1937 VG + (4.5) cr/ow

17 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.34 Feb. 1939 VG + (4.5) ow

18 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.35 Mar. 1939 miss CF (would be VG+)

19 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.32 Dec. 1938 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

20 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.33 Jan. 1939 VG + (4.5) ow

21 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.27 July. 1938 VG (4.0) ow

22 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.26 June. 1938 VG + (4.5) cr/ow

23 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.30 Oct. 1938 FN (6.0) ow

24 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.28 Aug. 1938 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

25 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.29 Sept. 1938 FN (6.0) ow

26 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.25 May. 1938 FN + (6.5) ow

27 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.24 Apr. 1938 G/VG (3.5) cr/ow

28 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.22 Feb. 1938 G + (2.5) cr/ow

29 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.23 Mar. 1938 G + (2.5) cr/ow

30 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.19 Nov. 1937 G/VG (3.0) ow/w

31 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.20 Dec. 1937 G - (1.8) cr/ow

32 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.21 Jan. 1938 VG/FN (5.0) ow

33 Tip Top Comics V.3 No.31 Nov. 1938 FN + (6.5) ow

34 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.18 Oct. 1937 VG + (4.5) ow

35 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.17 Sept. 1937 G+ (2.5) cr/ow

36 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.14 June. 1937 VG (4.0) ow

37 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.15 July. 1937 G (2.0) ow

38 Tip Top Comics V.1 No.6 Oct. 1936 VG (4.0) ow

39 Tip Top Comics V.2 No.16 Aug. 1937 VG/FN (5.0) ow

40 Detective Comics No.3 May. 1937 CGC grade (4.0) cr/ow

41 Detective Comics No.6 Aug. 1937 CGC grade (4.5) cr/ow

42 Detective Comics No.7 Sep. 1937 CGC grade (5.5) cr/ow

43 Detective Comics No.14 Apr. 1938 G/VG (3.0) cr/ow

44 Detective Comics No.15 May. 1938 CGC grade (6.0 cr/ow

45 Detective Comics No.16 June. 1938 CGC grade (8.0) ow

46 Detective Comics No. 17 July. 1938 CGC grade (6.0) ow/w

47 Detective Comics No.18 Aug. 1938 CGC grade (5.5) w

48 Detective Comics No.19 Sep. 1938 CGC grade (7.0) ow/w

49 Det. Picture Stories V.1 No.4 Mar. 1937 VG + (4.5) cr/ow

50 Ace Comics No.5 Aug. 1937 G (2.0) cr/ow

51 King Comics No.14 May. 1937 miss CF

52 King Comics No.25 Apr. 1938 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

53 Funny Pages The comic mag. V.1 No.4 Aug. 1936 G/VG (3.5) cr/ow

54 Funny Pages The comic mag. V.1 No.5 Sep. 1936 VG + (4.5) cr/ow

55 Funny Pages V.1 No.7 Dec.1936 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

56 Funny Pages V.1 No.8 Feb.1937 G+ (2.5) cr/ow

57 Funny Pages V.2 No.2 Sept. 1937 VG/FN (5.0) cr/ow

58 Funny Pages V.2 No.8 May. 1938 FN (6.0) ow

59 Funny Pages V.2 No.11 Nov. 1938 VG+ (4.5) cr/ow

60 Funny Picture Stories V.1 No.10 Sept. 1937 VG/FN (5.0) ow

61 Funny Picture Stories V.2 No.5 Jan. 1938 VG+ (4.5) cr/ow

62 Funny Picture Stories V.2 No.10 Sept.1938 FN + (6.5) cr/ow

63 Star Ranger No.8 Dec. 1937 VG (4.0) cr/ow

64 Funny Pages V.1 No.6 Nov. 1936nc

65 Champion Comics No.2 Dec. 1939nc

66 Champion Comics No.4 Nov. 1939nc

67 Wonder World Comics No.7 July. 1939nc centerfold detached

68 Daring Mystery Comics No.2 Feb. 1939

69 Silver Streak Comics No.1 Dec. 1939nc

70 King Comics Dec. 1938nc

71 "MANTOKA Maker of Indian Magic!" (Funny Pages? - arrow)

72 Mammoth Comics Hard Cover No.1 1937 G+ (2.5) cr/ow

73 Wow Comics No.2 Aug. 1936 G/VG (3.0) cr/ow

74 Wow Comics No.3 Sept. 1936 VG (4.0) cr/ow

75 Fantastic Comic No.2 Dec. 1939nc

76 Daring Mysterty Comics No.2 Feb. 1939 CGC grade (7.0) cr/ow

83 Fantastic Four Oct. 1979

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dark Knight

Dark Knight

Posted
Posted
For my money, if you are seriously interested in the pre-Superman era, go after the Wow #2. Extremely rare, first Eisner cover with great early artists. It is an amazing little run......jon

 

Shhhh!!! :pullhair:

 

hm I may go for this one now that Jon mentioned it :baiting:. Thanks for the info

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Theagenes

Theagenes

Posted
Posted
For my money, if you are seriously interested in the pre-Superman era, go after the Wow #2. Extremely rare, first Eisner cover with great early artists. It is an amazing little run......jon

 

Shhhh!!! :pullhair:

 

hm I may go for this one now that Jon mentioned it :baiting:. Thanks for the info

 

 

:slapfight:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dark Knight

Dark Knight

Posted
Posted
For my money, if you are seriously interested in the pre-Superman era, go after the Wow #2. Extremely rare, first Eisner cover with great early artists. It is an amazing little run......jon

 

Shhhh!!! :pullhair:

 

hm I may go for this one now that Jon mentioned it :baiting:. Thanks for the info

 

 

:slapfight:

 

:slapfight: I'm just kidding.. Good luck!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing