What is the rarest comic in your collection?

[Bo_Hogg]

As some of you know, I exclusively collect truly rare comics but I am not sure what is the rarest comic I own. According to Overstreet, it would be my Hoods Up #1 with 2 known copies in existence but I have seen about 8 of them for sale in my lifetime. Maybe it is my kokonut komics, a Hawaiian comic and gerber 9. I would post pictures but something is going on at photobucket, I could not highlight the img code to copy. Anybody know whats going on? Anyway let's see your rarest comic!

[Larryw7]

It's one of these three I suppose:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[seank]

[Tsp99]

Love that Jumbo 31.....

[143ksk]

I'm not sure any of these is rarer than the others, but as a group, these are the rarest books I have.

[TheWatcher]

I would post pictures but something is going on at photobucket, I could not highlight the img code to copy. Anybody know whats going on? Anyway let's see your rarest comic!

 

They revamped the interface. Now when you click on the IMG code tab, it automatically copies it for you (it'll say "Copied" in the field after you click on it)

 

[Straw-Man]

[Bo_Hogg]

 

 

Thanx for helping me out at photobucket. I didn't know what was going on. Ok here is kokonut 1 I have never seen another one for sale.

 

143 what kinda Archie NN comic is that? Is that in Overstreet? Have you ever seen the Holy Grail rare ARchie, Official boy scout outfitter?

[batman_fan]

 

Mr Parker, that is just so sweet

[nearmint]

I've sold most of my ultra-rare books, but I still have this one...

 

 

[Straw-Man]

I've sold most of my ultra-rare books, but I still have this one...

 

 

 

that is indeed a keeper. so nice.

[Weird Paper]

Probably this...

 

[telerites]

Probably this...

 

 

That's a beautiful book, Roger

[143ksk]

 

143 what kinda Archie NN comic is that? Is that in Overstreet? Have you ever seen the Holy Grail rare ARchie, Official boy scout outfitter?

 

Those are all Canadian Whites, so not listed in Overstreet.

 

I have never seen or heard of anyone who has seen the Boy Scout Outfitter. I'm not sure it exists

[Cimm]

Probably this one...

 

 

or this one...

 

[sacentaur]

Great thread Bo, not just the perceived rarest books in the hobby but the rarest books in each Boardie's collection. Fun to see 'em (thumbs u

 

Here's possibly mine:

 

 

 

 

 

[cheetah]

I've sold most of my ultra-rare books, but I still have this one...

 

 

 

that is indeed a keeper. so nice.

 

[The_Captain]

This would definitely be the rarest book that I own right now:

 

Action Comics 3 would be the second rarest.

[lotemo]

I'm not sure any of these is rarer than the others, but as a group, these are the rarest books I have.

 

Great books :applause:and that Archie Andrews is a tough one. I still need it plus the Super Comics reprint of Pep 22.

[KirbyJack]

I've got a couple that might be scarce; Power #2 was a Gerber no-show, but nothing really rare. I aspire to own an Adventure #24, though. Fave Flessel cover ever!