Moderns that are heating up on ebay! 71 71

[I like pie]

PP 2 cgc 9.8 vs WD 2 cgc 9.8

 

Suply - demand

one book is ten years old and the other a year

 

Did wd #2 have mass production defects as well?

[MrWeen]

I usually do not visit this thread, but 49 posts drew me in

 

all

 

 

Porn still taking up too much of your time.

 

 

I hear issue 24 of PP will feature the first appearance of......

 

[awakeintheashes]

I usually do not visit this thread, but 49 posts drew me in

 

all

 

 

Porn still taking up too much of your time.

 

 

I hear issue 24 of PP will feature the first appearance of......

 

 

Which will soon follow with a real life appearance by...

 

[Junkdrawer]

PP 2 cgc 9.8 vs WD 2 cgc 9.8

 

Suply - demand

one book is ten years old and the other a year

 

Did wd #2 have mass production defects as well?

A total of approx 1% of the total print run has been submitted so it's pure speculation that there is a common defect in the 4000+ books yet to be subbed.

[Legion HQ]

I'd hesitate to compare ANYTHING to Walking Dead. The last time I saw anything resembling the WD phenomenon is TMNT. So, what is that - every 20 years or so in Modern Comics, something like this in comics comes along that sweeps up the general public into a pop cultural frenzy, which then translates into those comics rising to and then sustaining 4-figure prices? (Bone is another title where the 1st issue is highly valued, but it's never had the frenzy WD has.)

 

Not saying PP doesn't have the potential. But setting WD-level expectations is likely to lead to disappointment. Also, genre fans (zombies) naturally gravitate to comics and collecting hobbies. Those types of fans I can see spending thousands of dollars on a comic. WW2 fans, not so much. But I'd love to be wrong here!

[bffnut]

Man, I completely forgot about the WW2 aspect. That certainly has broader appeal, but I would discount too much the broad appeal of zombies. I dislike horror movies, but I like zombies. Every female that I know likes zombie movies, but I feel I cant say the same for Peter Pan/WW2.

[I like pie]

PP 2 cgc 9.8 vs WD 2 cgc 9.8

 

Suply - demand

one book is ten years old and the other a year

 

Did wd #2 have mass production defects as well?

A total of approx 1% of the total print run has been submitted so it's pure speculation that there is a common defect in the 4000+ books yet to be subbed.

 

I wasn't trying to argue. I am not sure if wd #2 had the same issues. I'm sure there quite a few PP #2 9.8 raws out there but I'm also certain quite a lot haven't passed pre screen to this point.

[bffnut]

I dont think WD 2 had any mass issues, but it does have that all black back cover which highlights any flaws.

[Junkdrawer]

PP 2 cgc 9.8 vs WD 2 cgc 9.8

 

Suply - demand

one book is ten years old and the other a year

 

Did wd #2 have mass production defects as well?

A total of approx 1% of the total print run has been submitted so it's pure speculation that there is a common defect in the 4000+ books yet to be subbed.

 

I wasn't trying to argue. I am not sure if wd #2 had the same issues. I'm sure there quite a few PP #2 9.8 raws out there but I'm also certain quite a lot haven't passed pre screen to this point.

It's certainly a tough argument for me as I'm well stocked in WD 1 and PP 1 & up. I do need to see either bubble burst. I do think I will be bailing out on WD this season though, I don't feel the potential is the same as PP.

[paul747]

PP 2 cgc 9.8 vs WD 2 cgc 9.8

 

Suply - demand

one book is ten years old and the other a year

 

Did wd #2 have mass production defects as well?

A total of approx 1% of the total print run has been submitted so it's pure speculation that there is a common defect in the 4000+ books yet to be subbed.

 

I wasn't trying to argue. I am not sure if wd #2 had the same issues. I'm sure there quite a few PP #2 9.8 raws out there but I'm also certain quite a lot haven't passed pre screen to this point.

+1 if you call CGC they will tell you of the hundreds of #2 that did not screen for 9.4 or higher. i know one guy that sent 50 not one 9.8 it is a big defect almost every one i have seen has it

[paul747]

2. Considering demand. Walking dead is huge. However, PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience. If the show is quality, and the comic story can draw people in, things will explode. If not then, speculators will be looking to dump those stocks.

 

Not looking to argue, but want to discuss this point. You state "PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience." I assume you are talking about it being based on Peter Pan?

 

 

This isn't necessarily aimed only at Mike's Rack, so please anyone chime in: Is Peter Pan really a broader audience than the zombie genre?

its up there PP has huge international potential. if done right this will be huge !

[fastballspecial]

2. Considering demand. Walking dead is huge. However, PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience. If the show is quality, and the comic story can draw people in, things will explode. If not then, speculators will be looking to dump those stocks.

 

Not looking to argue, but want to discuss this point. You state "PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience." I assume you are talking about it being based on Peter Pan?

 

 

This isn't necessarily aimed only at Mike's Rack, so please anyone chime in: Is Peter Pan really a broader audience than the zombie genre?

its up there PP has huge international potential. if done right this will be huge !

 

No next question

 

[fastballspecial]

Hard to separate the speculators that have a vested interest in PP succeeding and the enthusiast who just likes the book.

 

See I think there are more speculators then enthusiasts here defending this book.

Own up to being one or the other when defending your arguments. It gives more validity in my opinion.

 

 

[natevegas]

Hard to separate the speculators that have a vested interest in PP succeeding and the enthusiast who just likes the book.

 

See I think there are more speculators then enthusiasts here defending this book.

Own up to being one or the other when defending your arguments. It gives more validity in my opinion.

 

You can't be both???

[ranx]

Bleeding cool has just reported Hollywood interest in day men...

[the authority]

Hard to separate the speculators that have a vested interest in PP succeeding and the enthusiast who just likes the book.

 

See I think there are more speculators then enthusiasts here defending this book.

Own up to being one or the other when defending your arguments. It gives more validity in my opinion.

 

You can't be both???

 

There is almost nothing I buy (unless it is personalized) that I don't intend to remarket at some point. I couldn't afford to read all I do if other people didn't help support my habit. That doesn't change the fact that I love comics or which comics I prefer. I always buy a lot of what I like the most which I guess goes hand in hand with promoting my speculative books.

 

Why would anybody promote something they didn't have a vested interest in ? Maybe they do it for speculatory reasons or maybe they want to keep reading the story ( like me with WD ). I think most people here have good intentions. They're promoting what they like and possibly speculating to boot.

[juggernaut]

2. Considering demand. Walking dead is huge. However, PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience. If the show is quality, and the comic story can draw people in, things will explode. If not then, speculators will be looking to dump those stocks.

 

Not looking to argue, but want to discuss this point. You state "PP has the potential to be even bigger because it is based on a subject matter that appeals to a broader audience." I assume you are talking about it being based on Peter Pan?

 

 

This isn't necessarily aimed only at Mike's Rack, so please anyone chime in: Is Peter Pan really a broader audience than the zombie genre?

its up there PP has huge international potential. if done right this will be huge !

 

No next question

 

PP has the potential to be even bigger than Walking Dead. What have you been smokin'? You can't possible think that a subject matter on WW2 & Nazi's is going to appeal to a larger audience.

[I like pie]

The wise people bought PP when it was @$150 or under and have since sold them

[juggernaut]

The wise people bought PP when it was @$150 or under and have since sold them

 

Well said.

[THB]

The wise people bought PP when it was @$150 at cover and have since sold them

 

Helped you there.