Batman 232 please grade

[NewtSamson]

I figured since now I can upload Higher resolutioned images that I'd put up a comic I put up a few months ago.

I thought this comic was better than you guys were saying, but didn't realise you weren't seeing a good image of it.

Any way here is again my copy of Batman 232

(and yea I downsized the image, Aces)

FRONT COVER

BACK COVER

[divad]

Newt - still waaaaaaaaay too big. Keep the same resolution (200 dpi or better) and re-size to a 4 or 5" width, maintain proportions, and compress to 35% - any questions?

[DKB]

Newt - still waaaaaaaaay too big. Keep the same resolution (200 dpi or better) and re-size to a 4 or 5" width, maintain proportions, and compress to 35% - any questions?

 

Orrrr...you get broadband.

[divad]

Newt - still waaaaaaaaay too big. Keep the same resolution (200 dpi or better) and re-size to a 4 or 5" width, maintain proportions, and compress to 35% - any questions?

 

Orrrr...you get broadband.

 

It's not the download speed that bothers me DK - I like to see the whole book on my screen and let my eyes do the work. I'd need a 30" monitor to see this friggin' whole book!

[Murph]

Good sized scans, keep them this size. It's the only way to give a decent opinion from a scan. I think this one is VG/F or F-.

 

Brian

[divad]

Good sized scans, keep them this size. It's the only way to give a decent opinion from a scan. I think this one is VG/F or F-.

 

Brian

 

Brian,

I disagree - larger than life is just that - LARGER THAN LIFE. It distorts the relative perpective of the flaws compared to the whole of the book.

[Murph]

The only way to grade a book is to be able to see it. To do that you have to have a big scan. Bigger scans show all of the book, smaller scans hide things.

 

Brian

[divad]

The only way to grade a book is to be able to see it. To do that you have to have a big scan. Bigger scans show all of the book, smaller scans hide things.

 

Brian

 

Hulk smash puny scans!

[uclapeterg]

I'm giving it a 5.5.

[FFB]

3.5 to 4.0 due to HUGE crease on the right edge that most people didn't see last time either.

[Aces]

A nice VG(4.0)

 

 

That miscut along the bottom right is as annoying as the crease FFB.

[kryptonitecomics]

3.5 to 4.0 due to HUGE crease on the right edge that most people didn't see last time either.

 

 

I still don't see it for the most part....is it on the front right in the middle of the edge??

 

If so than I agree with FFB...... 4.0

 

What's up with the cut on that book??? Thaey back looks terrible

[FFB]

3.5 to 4.0 due to HUGE crease on the right edge that most people didn't see last time either.

 

 

I still don't see it for the most part....is it on the front right in the middle of the edge??

 

If so than I agree with FFB...... 4.0

 

What's up with the cut on that book??? Thaey back looks terrible

 

Here is the crease. Look between the red lines:

 

[uclapeterg]

I'm giving it a 5.5.

 

oops, I give it a 4.0 .

[seank]

VG