CLOSED!: ASM 129 (Mark Jewelers Insert) Punisher (PRIZE TO WINNER)

[1904 Comics]

grades were posted this morning!

12-hour Guess This Grade forum (ends 8:30pm PST) and I'll post the results.

the first person to exactly guess both the grade and page quality correctly, wins a free spidey comic. we'll make it a mystery one

 

Rules for submitting:

you only get 1 guess (no reference ranges)

must match both the grade and page quality exactly to win

any grades with missing page quality will be excluded from the prize

any change in decision (edits to OP) after I announce the results will be excluded from entry

if there are multiple correct answers, the person who has the earliest time stamp is

if noone gets it right, then no prize will be awarded

 

thanks for looking!

 

[vaillant]

6.5/7.0 for the various spine breaks, corner wear and there is also a hint of rust migration from another book on the BC, near the upper staple. I don’t care about that, but I think CGC does (not sure about Overstreet).

[timfinz]

This is a pretty nice book overall. The spine creases are the biggest culprit here but I only see one that breaks colour. There is a slight scuff along the Punisher's right abdomen and you do have some blunted or abraded corners but nothing substantial. The inked star above the Punisher's shoulder IMO does not detract from this book. I am guessing this one should be somewhere in the range of 7.5 to 8.0 IMHO. Leaning towards the 7.5 tho (thumbs u

[ChrisInBaltimore]

A 129 with the Mark Jeweler in it? Man that is sweet.

 

 

Oh and other grades seem about on par. I'd think an 8.0 but what do I know....

[GAMBIT]

7.0/7.5

[comicsnyc22]

7.5, but get that pressed.

[marvelcollector]

7.0

[1904 Comics]

7.5, but get that pressed.

 

book was pressed by CCS. good luck everyone!

[Mishmashman]

8.0

[Wilson3d]

8.0. OWTW pages.

[ARK]

8.5

[Punisher_64-migration]

7.5 OW/W is my guess

[jsilverjanet]

8.5 but a good shot at 9.0

[1904 Comics]

8.0. OW/W pages.

 

7.5 OW/W is my guess

[ChicksCosmiComics]

I will go 9.0 I wonder if it is harder to press a book with the insert making the book a lot thicker?

[Red84]

7.5 off white to white pages

[Hulksdaddy1]

8.5

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

8.0. OWTW pages.

 

This was going to be my guess but Wilson pegged it first! (thumbs u

 

 

[bighairjer]

8.5 oww

[Jaydogrules]

This is a pretty nice book overall. The spine creases are the biggest culprit here but I only see one that breaks colour. There is a slight scuff along the Punisher's right abdomen and you do have some blunted or abraded corners but nothing substantial. The inked star above the Punisher's shoulder IMO does not detract from this book. I am guessing this one should be somewhere in the range of 7.5 to 8.0 IMHO. Leaning towards the 7.5 tho (thumbs u

 

I notice a lot of these Mark Jewelers comics have that star stamp somewhere on them. Anyone know what's up with that, or if CGC actually deducts for those, or if they just treat them as the equivalent to a date stamp?

 

-J.