PGM Avengers #8 (1964)

[popnecker]

Thanks for any help grading this copy of Avengers #8 -

 

 

[Lost]

7.5/8

[timfinz]

6.0 IMHO! There are three separate locations where there are pieces that are missing. This is the reason for my grade.

The book certainly appears better than that but when you have missing pieces I can't see awarding a higher grade. I am not sure others will have the same view point as myself.

[dman72]

7.5

[Spiderphill]

Text book 7.5

[rjpb]

7.0

[sassemble]

 

Easy 7.0/7.5 (thumbs u

[timfinz]

Am I missing something here besides the missing pieces on this book?

Would CGC really allow a grade above 7.0 for a book that has a missing piece? Let alone three. I know that they are not large but they are missing pieces. And they do not appear to be production related! Really?

Not to mention the small smudge in the middle of the front cover!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Where is divad? Why isn't he weighing in on this one??

[vaillant]

6.5, IMO – and not only for the missing piece. It has several spine creases and pretty rounded corners.

[divad]

7.0

 

This. Very nice copy that any of us would want in our collections.

[vaillant]

At this point I think I may not be able to grade books in the 7.0-7.5 range.

This does not look like a 7.0 to me, maybe I have too high expectations for FVF.

[Captain_Pike]

7.0/7.5

[Comic Consortium]

7

[cpannell]

7.5

[southerncross]

6.0

[Primetime]

6.5

[Mr. Hog]

6.5, IMO – and not only for the missing piece. It has several spine creases and pretty rounded corners.

 

+1 for me too

[Mishmashman]

7.5

[comicsrlife-migration]

I think 6.0 the defects add up maybe a 6.5 if lucky

[popnecker]

Thanks for the help guys. Interesting that this one brought out some pretty varied grades.