PGM - Batman #198 (80 Page Giant)

[Chip Cataldo]

Yes, that's a fingerprint. There are a few NCB spine tics/creases and a small bit of spine crumpling up top. Otherwise...?

 

 

 

Peace,

 

Chip

[stanley1883]

So stating the obvious, I'm not one of the best graders here but I really can't see why it would be less than a 7.5 :shrug:

[timfinz]

8.0 IMHO!

 

[Chip Cataldo]

I'd love to hear the reasonings behind these low grades. The "eye test" suggests it's a bunch higher than that. I'm honestly curious.

 

Peace,

 

Chip

[AnhDepTrai]

Isn't it a 4+ inches crease on back cover? run from half of the book (left edge to the bottom edge)? if there is a crease that long, 7.5 is way too high.

[timfinz]

I'd love to hear the reasonings behind these low grades. The "eye test" suggests it's a bunch higher than that. I'm honestly curious.

 

Peace,

 

Chip

Hey Chip,

If you can submit larger higher res scans it would help in providing you more accurate grading assessment.

Cheers!

Tim

[southerncross]

7.0, looks like crease on back cover, front cover presents well, shame on finger print, does happen from time to time. (thumbs u

[timfinz]

Isn't it a 4+ inches crease on back cover? run from half of the book (left edge to the bottom edge)? if there is a crease that long, 7.5 is way too high.

Very good eye ADT! I can see it now! Too much light during the day and I couldn't see it on my screen! But there it is!

I'll have to revise my grade - that large CB crease combined with the "finger print smudges" on the front cover!

6.0 IMHO!