Journey Into Mystery 83. What did CGC say?(UPDATED WITH CORRECT BACK COVER)

[johnny54321]

thoughts?

[Junkdrawer]

4.5

[oakman29]

Better be 4.0 or I'm resubbing mine.

[seredynskib]

3.5 would be my guess..... The suspense is killing me!

[Darkowl]

4.5

[thehumantorch]

4.0, possibly 3.5

[Kevin.J]

That looks quite similar to mine, I have always thought that my copy was trimmed on the right hand side, I still do...99% certain.

I have just sent it off so I guess I will find out for sure soon.

The more copies I see like this give me slight hope...not really

 

I think yours will be a 4.0

[The-Collector]

4.0

[VintageComics]

Hard to say from the smaller pics but I'm going to say no less than 2.0 and no more than 2.5

 

(thumbs u

[timfinz]

3.0 IMHO!

It's a nice looking copy but the combination of stress lines, overall wear and missing pieces on the back cover are how I arrived at my grade!

[rjpb]

Hard to tell from the photos with the glare, but the only way that gets a 4.5 is if it's in a PGX holder.

 

I'd say 2.5, but aside from the chunk out of the back cover a decent looking low grade. Anything over a 3.0 is a gift grade.

[thunsicker]

I'm at 4.0.

 

EDIT: I missed the chunk out of the back cover. Brings it down to 3.0.

[Dark Knight]

I'd say a 3.0 due to the chunk missing at the back cover.

[Hulksdaddy1]

4.0-4.5

[Fantastic Thor]

3.5

Sexy to off sexy pages !!

[tjanse]

4.5

[AnhDepTrai]

3.0

 

are those staples replaced? Look perfectly white and new.

 

2.5 if replaced

[johnny54321]

Sheesh, I'm dumb. I was wondering why the grades were so low, then I realized I posted the WRONG back cover. The back cover I posted was from my IH #1 that graded a 2.0.

Im so sorry I threw you guys off.

 

Here is the correct back cover for JIM 83

 

[toro]

Hard to say from the smaller pics but I'm going to say no less than 2.0 and no more than 2.5

 

(thumbs u

 

+1

[tjanse]

So what was the grade?