PGM ASM1 updated w grade

[VuDuPriest]

Just curious about opinions,

PQ is OWW

I'll post the CGC grade in a couple days, if anyone cares.

Thanks

 

 

 

 

 

[ivegotneatstuff]

6.0

 

[Mark 1]

4.0

[Columbia Comics]

3.0 at best...looks killer on the front cover. Then you see the piece missing from the back

[The_SandMan]

I was shooting for 5.5 until I saw that chunk out of the back. Not sure how much they'll beat you up over this but CGC hasn't been very generous this year

[Chicago Boy]

is the top trimmed?

[VuDuPriest]

Blue label so no trim.

[Diaolos]

Was thinking trim as well if blue label I would say 4.0 due to missing piece in their back

[Diaolos]

I was shooting for 5.5 until I saw that chunk out of the back. Not sure how much they'll beat you up over this but CGC hasn't been very generous this year

I

 

have a 5.0 comparing the front to mine it looks 7.0

[fastballspecial]

Guessing at 5.5 for missing chunk. Awesome front cover.

 

[makeminemego]

No trim as you can see a faint trail of the registration line at the bottom of the cover.......too bad about the b/c chunk missing.

 

3.5

[cousin itt]

Could it get a green label for the missing chunk?

 

Also, it looks like there's a tape pull above spidey's left hand.

[Primetime]

3.5 due to the chunk. I think CGC would be loose and grade this a 4.0 though

[Spidey-fan73]

3-3.5

[Diaolos]

well... grade please

[DR.X]

the size of the piece out of the back cover is considerable. I can't see this book going higher than 3.5 but would call it a bit lower myself. more like a 3.0.

[VuDuPriest]

Thanks to everyone for giving your opinions!

The CGC grade is 3.0.

I thought it was a little harsh but still very happy with the book.

And happy that no one guessed lower than the assigned grade!

 

[rjpb]

I like books like this when it comes to pricey comics. You get rock solid front cover eye-appeal at a great reduction due to a major back cover flaw. I would value this book at more than your average 3.0.

[DR.X]

Thanks to everyone for giving your opinions!

The CGC grade is 3.0.

I thought it was a little harsh but still very happy with the book.

And happy that no one guessed lower than the assigned grade!

 

[rec1978]

Wow! This is an absolutely beautiful 3.0.