2015 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 128

[s-man]

ASM #19 - 6.5

ASM #129 - 8.0

SSoSV - 9.0

ST - 3.0

[Still Only 35c]

Answer Key

 

No bonus points for the double cover grades?

[thirdgreenham]

I'm in trouble.

[zuckuss2003]

I am really doing poorly on these books.

[Cascaders27]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

[Gsims718]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

It was a double cover. The outer cover was 9.0

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Hey Blowie, Have you ever considered buying vuescan?

 

I did the raw scans with my old laptop which had a licensed Vuescan. That laptop died a day before the Tournament.

 

I'm still setting the new laptop up. Haven't gotten around to getting Vuescan.

[1Cool]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

Double cover - outside was a 9.0

[thunsicker]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

 

Because it was a double cover and the cover you could see was a 9.0.

[zuckuss2003]

So, tape on a comic can still get a 6.5? For some reason I thought max was 4.5

[1Cool]

How did Comicdey do?

[thunsicker]

Hey Blowie, Have you ever considered buying vuescan?

 

I did the raw scans with my old laptop which had a licensed Vuescan. That laptop died a day before the Tournament.

 

I'm still setting the new laptop up. Haven't gotten around to getting Vuescan.

 

Just wondering if we all needed to pitch in...

[HighStakesComics]

ASM 129 crushed me

[thunsicker]

So, tape on a comic can still get a 6.5? For some reason I thought max was 4.5

 

I believe they currently just grade it as if the tape isn't there (except for tape stain?) and grade it as if splits or such being sealed by the tape are.

[HarveySwick]

ASM 129 crushed me

Ditto.

[HighStakesComics]

So, tape on a comic can still get a 6.5? For some reason I thought max was 4.5

 

I believe they currently just grade it as if the tape isn't there (except for tape stain?) and grade it as if splits or such being sealed by the tape are.

 

Shhhh

[Boboset]

How did Comicdey do?

 

Probably quite well.

 

[Gsims718]

So, tape on a comic can still get a 6.5? For some reason I thought max was 4.5

 

I believe they currently just grade it as if the tape isn't there (except for tape stain?) and grade it as if splits or such being sealed by the tape are.

They definitely deduct for tape now. If the tape is holding on a piece they act like it isn't.

[jaybuck43]

ASM 129 crushed me

Ditto.

You probably still beat me swickles

[B3AST]

55 if I did my math right, JollyComics?