2015 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 128

[BlowUpTheMoon]

If you see a score of (-20) it means the contestant did not submit grades.

 

__________________________________________________________

spideyfan76 17-1 [39]

Warlord 0-18 [-20]

 

Musicmeta 11-6 [-20]

Unca Scrooge 11-7 [75]

 

godquest 14-5 [37]

Leroys311 10-9 [32]

 

Shark 17-5 [60]

snowman28 7-9 [21]

 

roach04 14-6 [34]

Shadow 9-7 [65]

 

toro 14-4 [75]

W16227 7-9 [52]

 

timern 14-7 [67]

CostasA 9-6 [52]

 

everydayastory 16-4 [45]

Comic Book Guy 4-10 [29]

 

Barbarian 16-3 [65]

mrwoogieman 0-18 [60]

 

quadman78 12-7 [77]

FutureFlash 11-7 [29]

 

thirdgreenham 14-5 [55]

Max Carnage 9-8 [37]

 

Jimbo_707 13-4 [44]

WEBHEAD 8-8 [62]

 

Jeffro™ 12-5 [44]

Fastballspecial 8-7 [37]

 

Paddy_McShillihan 15-4 [-20]

s-man 6-10 [77]

 

HarveySwick 11-5 [37]

jaybuck43 12-9 [26]

 

Dark Knight 13-3 [41]

slym2none 4-12 [62]

 

ItsJustRyan 16-2 [57]

RockMyAmadeus 0-18 [-20]

 

KPR Comics 10-6 [54]

thunsicker 10-6 [60]

 

1cool 13-5 [57]

comicdey 9-8 [93]

 

Awax 13-4 [39]

THB 8-9 [49]

 

rjpb 12-5 [90]

krighton 10-8 [31]

 

marmat 16-4 [75]

Cascaders27 5-11 [34]

 

djpinkpanther67 12-6 [36]

Huichillo 11-8 [-20]

 

ARK 16-4 [90]

Tnerb 4-10 [-20]

 

The-Collector 16-3 [55]

jsilverjanet 0-18 [60]

 

boatfund 12-7 [75]

paradigmcomics 11-7 [32]

 

BorderlineHoarder 14-5 [90]

aszumilo 9-9 [31]

 

jhutton2 12-4 [60]

Jester Hats 9-9 [47]

 

Wilson3d 12-5 [41]

DavidTheDavid 10-8 [24]

 

Pirate 14-4 [37]

stanley1883 7-10 [27]

 

porky 10-5 [65]

Plantman 9-6 [68]

 

letsgrumble 14-3 [45]

collector_bill 0-18 [35]

 

LordRahl 20-2 [75]

topofthetotem 0-18 [-20]

 

Rogue79 11-6 [57]

shadroch 11-7 [36]

 

Red84 14-5 [34]

Gsims718 10-9 [52]

 

01TheDude 13-4 [47]

yoddler 6-7 [32]

 

Thanos88 14-6 [62]

Amazing Spidey 9-7 [75]

 

SNiPER 14-4 [68]

Chadwick 6-8 [60]

 

Beige 11-6 [39]

wipple 11-7 [52]

 

eeb03 16-4 [26]

gradejunky 4-10 [42]

 

oakman29 16-3 [44]

Mike's Rack 0-18 [90]

 

sd2416 12-7 [24]

bighairjer 11-7 [78]

 

Tempus Fugit 16-6 [54]

John R 9-8 [57]

 

TheGeneral 19-6 [50]

manicnerd 8-8 [42]

 

zuckuss2003 13-5 [37]

phantalien 8-7 [-20]

 

trmoore54 16-4 [47]

IncredibleHauck 7-12 [65]

 

AJD 13-6 [68]

canickus 12-9 [75]

 

Boboset 13-3 [65]

Balham's Finest 0-18 [57]

 

blazincomics 21-3 [63]

NinjaSealed 0-18 [44]

 

mccollect 10-6 [67]

Richard The Man 10-6 [29]

 

SonOfWolF 13-5 [62]

Silver 8-7 [52]

 

Azkaban 13-4 [42]

Scturo 8-9 [52]

 

Park 12-5 [60]

rfoiii 10-8 [42]

 

Humantop 16-4 [36]

catrick339 5-11 [75]

 

InvstmntComcSuply 12-6 [60]

paul747 10-7 [55]

 

NuffSaid57 13-3 [40]

topcat54 5-14 [23]

 

MediumLover 19-4 [57]

fuggit 0-18 [-20]

 

Hado 12-7 [52]

Jeffreykli 11-7 [47]

 

AnhDepTrai 14-5 [45]

Fantastic Thor 8-8 [37]

 

comicdonna 17-6 [37]

iceman399 7-7 [62]

 

He11blazer 14-6 [37]

AlexH 10-8 [78]

 

JollyComics 14-4 [52]

B3AST 6-9 [55]

 

SpideyFein 10-5 [-20]

jessebrook1 9-6 [31]

 

Black Lantern 14-3 [57]

drewincanada 0-18 [68]

 

[Still Only 35c]

The slabbed books:

 

 

 

 

 

Hang on Blowie... SSoSV = 9.4 not 9.0. I was grading as CGC would, ie. grade defined by best cover. I think if we are going to include double covers in the contest, the rules for grading should be defined.

[Gsims718]

I won

 

Onto the round of 64

[thunsicker]

So we all know how we did, but unless our opponent posted his grades we don't see how they did. Any clue as to when the results will be posted so I can stop refreshing this page and get to my meeting?

 

EDIT: Spoke too soon.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

How did Comicdey do?

 

Probably quite well.

 

High score of 93

[Azkaban]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

 

Because it was a double cover and the cover you could see was a 9.0.

 

I thought we were giving it the grade we thought CGC would give it which was a 9.4, which is what I graded it as

[letsgrumble]

Answer Key

 

ASM 19 =

 

ASM 129 =

 

SSoSV 1 =

 

 

ST 114 =

[Gsims718]

The slabbed books:

 

 

 

 

 

Hang on Blowie... SSoSV = 9.4 not 9.0. I was grading as CGC would, ie. grade defined by best cover. I think if we are going to include double covers in the contest, the rules for grading should be defined.

I think this is a joke, right?

[HarveySwick]

ASM 129 crushed me

Ditto.

You probably still beat me swickles

[zuckuss2003]

Wow, I skate by due to a no submit. Well, I need to figure out grading the large scans better.

[jaybuck43]

You did win buddy

[1Cool]

The slabbed books:

 

 

 

 

 

Hang on Blowie... SSoSV = 9.4 not 9.0. I was grading as CGC would, ie. grade defined by best cover. I think if we are going to include double covers in the contest, the rules for grading should be defined.

You graded it without being able to see it?

[catrick339]

Hey, lookie there!

 

I'm NEVER that close.

 

Spot on with the Spidey 19 and SSoSV, half grade off on the other two.

 

(Does Happy Dance)

[jhutton2]

yeah, made it through to the next round!

[HarveySwick]

You did win buddy

 

Neither of us should be proud of that showing.

[1Cool]

How did Comicdey do?

 

Probably quite well.

 

I'd say so. I think his 93 was the high score for the round. Crushed by the champ.

[oakman29]

Back on the sidelines for me.

[Gsims718]

I'm just happy I didn't have a first round exit.

[Red84]

Congrats to Gsims. May you be successful in your title defense!

[Boboset]

I'm just happy I didn't have a first round exit.

Same. I was scurred.