2015 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 128

[Still Only 35c]

At least its clear how we grade DC's now and it didn't impact my scores regardless (I graded it 9.2).

 

Anyway, onto the next round; up against timern who did well this round...

[thirdgreenham]

68 points and heading to the stands for the next round.

 

At least I went out swinging.

 

You can play pick up with all the losers.

[porky]

68 points and heading to the stands for the next round.

 

At least I went out swinging.

 

65 and done here. Be movin on to the next round of the grade on the slab counted for that double cover :-/

[slym2none]

Nailed the first two books and crushed my competition!

 

Dark Knight 13-3 [41]

slym2none 4-12 [62]

 

#15 seed upset right here!!!

 

 

 

 

-slym

 

[Dark Knight]

Nailed the first two books and crushed my competition!

 

Dark Knight 13-3 [41]

slym2none 4-12 [62]

 

 

 

 

-slym

 

Congrats Slym I failed . I was 1 full grade under for the first three and only nailed the last

[slym2none]

Thanks, it is an honor to get this far!

 

 

 

 

-slym

[roach04]

I did well...grossly overgraded 2 of them...and grossly undergraded the other 2.

 

It was a honour to get a "You Participated" badge.

 

 

[sckao]

 

Congrats to everyone moving on to the Round of 64.

 

For those ONE and DONE, better luck next year!

 

(Selection Sunday is coming for the REAL March Madness Pools!)

[Mike's Rack]

Back on the sidelines for me.

[Awax]

[Comicdey]

How did Comicdey do?

 

Probably quite well.

 

High score of 93

 

Holy carp

 

The only one I missed was the double cover cause I graded it 9.2 and didn't read it was a double cover cause I graded it so fast :: I must have averaged it in my mind.

[jsilverjanet]

Back on the sidelines for me.

same

 

[gradejunky]

I'm sorry, but I think CGC is smokin crack for real. I'm losing faith in their grading of comic books.

[Hado]

Limping on to the next round

 

[aszumilo]

I rushed my grades this morning before I left for work, because I wasn't sure if I would be home in time for the deadline.

 

ASM #19 - 8.0

ASM #129 - 7.0

SSoSV - 7.5

ST - 4.5

[Jester Hats]

yeah, made it through to the next round!

Good job (thumbs u

...

[LordRahl]

I'm sorry, but I think CGC is smokin crack for real. I'm losing faith in their grading of comic books.

 

Everybody thinks they are an expert

[Barbarian]

My goal for the tournament is now complete with a very respectable 65 score on a tough opponent.

Everything now is a bonus.

 

Hey Quadman, still enjoying that TWD 1 I sent you?

 

Just wanna tell you something...

 

 

 

 

[Humantop]

Humantop 16-4 [36]

catrick339 5-11 [75]

 

see you guys next year... I think I undergrade some of them..

 

[jimbo_707]

Answer Key

 

I'm confused, was the SSoSV a 9 or a 9.4 (as indicated by the scan of it graded?)

 

Because it was a double cover and the cover you could see was a 9.0.

 

I thought we were giving it the grade we thought CGC would give it which was a 9.4, which is what I graded it as

Agreed (although I guessed 9.6 for the inner cover). My opponent beat me by quite a few points, so it probably wouldn't have changed my results, but that issue could have made a difference in some match-ups.