2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Seeding Round

[Red84]

10 and 8

Boo yah!

[Comicdey]

I graded the lot of em in less than 2 minutes on my iPhone.

 

Pretty sure I ended up 20-5. (On all 10 books)

 

 

Make that 14-3 only taking the first 7 books ::

 

[Red84]

The seeding records, courtesy of sckao.

 

Two people who submitted grades after 10p will be added in, probably at the end of the list.

 

 

W16227 22-0

 

spidermanbeyond 24-1

 

DavidTheDavid 18-1

 

TheGeneral 18-1

 

canickus 24-2

 

boatfund 21-2

 

kav 19-2

 

DeadOne 19-2

 

SNiPER 18-2

 

porky 18-2

 

Ron Rau 18-2

 

jaybes 17-2

 

1Cool 16-2

 

TrapezeTony 15-2

 

427Impalers 21-3

 

jhutton2 21-3

 

John R 21-3

 

djpinkpanther67 17-3

 

Thanos88 17-3

 

THB 16-3

 

FutureFlash 16-3

 

Jollycomics 16-3

 

KryptoMayor 15-3

 

KPR Comics 15-3

 

eeb03 15-3

 

Revat 19-4

 

HighStakesComics 14-3

 

Hado 14-3

 

marmat 14-3

 

Warlord 14-3

 

BlackLantern 14-3

 

comicdey 14-3

 

Wilson3d 23-5

 

Tempus Fugit 17-4

 

cheta42 17-4

 

oakman29 17-4

 

Cascaders27 17-4

 

mar-vell 16-4

 

old dano 20-5

 

snowman28 16-4

 

Michelangelo 15-4

 

ss5rmp 14-4

 

drewincanada 14-4

 

rfoii 14-4

 

B3AST 14-4

 

LordRahl 17-5

 

Jeffro 17-5

 

SonOfWolF 17-5

 

Mike's Rack 13-4

 

letsgrumble 13-4

 

MustEatBrains 16-5

 

Azkaban 16-5

 

Rogue79 15-5

 

Shadow 17-6

 

Columbia Comics 14-5

 

Fastballspecial 14-5

 

notbrook 14-5

 

thirdgreenham 14-5

 

Richard The Man 14-5

 

BorderlineHoarder 14-5

 

thunsicker 13-5

 

AJD 10-4

 

pjray55 15-6

 

mccollect 12-5

 

zuulioso 12-5

 

Grantley Goddard 12-5

 

Mio 12-5

 

Paddy_McShillihan 12-5

 

quadman78 12-5

 

RICK STARR 12-5

 

jsilverjanet 12-5

 

AlexH 14-6

 

jaybuck43 11-5

 

SpideyFein 13-6

 

Dark Knight 12-6

 

wipple 12-6

 

ninanina 12-6

 

musicmeta 12-6

 

iceman399 14-7

 

Conan_Aficionado 12-6

 

MetalPSI 13-7

 

AL Comics 11-6

 

Montezuma 11-6

 

jimbo_707 11-6

 

Scturo 11-6

 

Omaha-CGC-Comics 11-6

 

toro 11-6

 

byosti 11-6

 

trmoore54 12-7

 

Unca Scrooge 12-7

 

paradigmcomics 10-6

 

collector_bill 12-8

 

Amazing Spidey 12-8

 

01TheDude 10-7

 

Couchy81 10-7

 

Silver 12-9

 

Red84 8-6

 

comicdonna 8-6

 

WEBHEAD 10-8

 

jessebrook1 8-7

 

spideyfan76 9-8

 

manicnerd 11-10

 

fiberbiskit 7-7

 

Plantman 8-8

 

s-man 8-9

 

Based on my math I'm pretty sure I am 10-8 instead of 8-6

[oakman29]

The seeding records, courtesy of sckao.

 

Two people who submitted grades after 10p will be added in, probably at the end of the list.

 

 

W16227 22-0

 

spidermanbeyond 24-1

 

DavidTheDavid 18-1

 

TheGeneral 18-1

 

canickus 24-2

 

boatfund 21-2

 

kav 19-2

 

DeadOne 19-2

 

SNiPER 18-2

 

porky 18-2

 

Ron Rau 18-2

 

jaybes 17-2

 

1Cool 16-2

 

TrapezeTony 15-2

 

427Impalers 21-3

 

jhutton2 21-3

 

John R 21-3

 

djpinkpanther67 17-3

 

Thanos88 17-3

 

THB 16-3

 

FutureFlash 16-3

 

Jollycomics 16-3

 

KryptoMayor 15-3

 

KPR Comics 15-3

 

eeb03 15-3

 

Revat 19-4

 

HighStakesComics 14-3

 

Hado 14-3

 

marmat 14-3

 

Warlord 14-3

 

BlackLantern 14-3

 

comicdey 14-3

 

Wilson3d 23-5

 

Tempus Fugit 17-4

 

cheta42 17-4

 

oakman29 17-4

 

Cascaders27 17-4

 

mar-vell 16-4

 

old dano 20-5

 

snowman28 16-4

 

Michelangelo 15-4

 

ss5rmp 14-4

 

drewincanada 14-4

 

rfoii 14-4

 

B3AST 14-4

 

LordRahl 17-5

 

Jeffro 17-5

 

SonOfWolF 17-5

 

Mike's Rack 13-4

 

letsgrumble 13-4

 

MustEatBrains 16-5

 

Azkaban 16-5

 

Rogue79 15-5

 

Shadow 17-6

 

Columbia Comics 14-5

 

Fastballspecial 14-5

 

notbrook 14-5

 

thirdgreenham 14-5

 

Richard The Man 14-5

 

BorderlineHoarder 14-5

 

thunsicker 13-5

 

AJD 10-4

 

pjray55 15-6

 

mccollect 12-5

 

zuulioso 12-5

 

Grantley Goddard 12-5

 

Mio 12-5

 

Paddy_McShillihan 12-5

 

quadman78 12-5

 

RICK STARR 12-5

 

jsilverjanet 12-5

 

AlexH 14-6

 

jaybuck43 11-5

 

SpideyFein 13-6

 

Dark Knight 12-6

 

wipple 12-6

 

ninanina 12-6

 

musicmeta 12-6

 

iceman399 14-7

 

Conan_Aficionado 12-6

 

MetalPSI 13-7

 

AL Comics 11-6

 

Montezuma 11-6

 

jimbo_707 11-6

 

Scturo 11-6

 

Omaha-CGC-Comics 11-6

 

toro 11-6

 

byosti 11-6

 

trmoore54 12-7

 

Unca Scrooge 12-7

 

paradigmcomics 10-6

 

collector_bill 12-8

 

Amazing Spidey 12-8

 

01TheDude 10-7

 

Couchy81 10-7

 

Silver 12-9

 

Red84 8-6

 

comicdonna 8-6

 

WEBHEAD 10-8

 

jessebrook1 8-7

 

spideyfan76 9-8

 

manicnerd 11-10

 

fiberbiskit 7-7

 

Plantman 8-8

 

s-man 8-9

 

Based on my math I'm pretty sure I am 10-8 instead of 8-6

 

Mine is off as well. Can we get a recalculation please.

[Azkaban]

Mine doesn't look right either or maybe I'm doing it wrong

[oakman29]

The seeding records, courtesy of sckao.

 

Two people who submitted grades after 10p will be added in, probably at the end of the list.

 

 

W16227 22-0

 

spidermanbeyond 24-1

 

DavidTheDavid 18-1

 

TheGeneral 18-1

 

canickus 24-2

 

boatfund 21-2

 

kav 19-2

 

DeadOne 19-2

 

SNiPER 18-2

 

porky 18-2

 

Ron Rau 18-2

 

jaybes 17-2

 

1Cool 16-2

 

TrapezeTony 15-2

 

427Impalers 21-3

 

jhutton2 21-3

 

John R 21-3

 

djpinkpanther67 17-3

 

Thanos88 17-3

 

THB 16-3

 

FutureFlash 16-3

 

Jollycomics 16-3

 

KryptoMayor 15-3

 

KPR Comics 15-3

 

eeb03 15-3

 

Revat 19-4

 

HighStakesComics 14-3

 

Hado 14-3

 

marmat 14-3

 

Warlord 14-3

 

BlackLantern 14-3

 

comicdey 14-3

 

Wilson3d 23-5

 

Tempus Fugit 17-4

 

cheta42 17-4

 

oakman29 17-4

 

Cascaders27 17-4

 

mar-vell 16-4

 

old dano 20-5

 

snowman28 16-4

 

Michelangelo 15-4

 

ss5rmp 14-4

 

drewincanada 14-4

 

rfoii 14-4

 

B3AST 14-4

 

LordRahl 17-5

 

Jeffro 17-5

 

SonOfWolF 17-5

 

Mike's Rack 13-4

 

letsgrumble 13-4

 

MustEatBrains 16-5

 

Azkaban 16-5

 

Rogue79 15-5

 

Shadow 17-6

 

Columbia Comics 14-5

 

Fastballspecial 14-5

 

notbrook 14-5

 

thirdgreenham 14-5

 

Richard The Man 14-5

 

BorderlineHoarder 14-5

 

thunsicker 13-5

 

AJD 10-4

 

pjray55 15-6

 

mccollect 12-5

 

zuulioso 12-5

 

Grantley Goddard 12-5

 

Mio 12-5

 

Paddy_McShillihan 12-5

 

quadman78 12-5

 

RICK STARR 12-5

 

jsilverjanet 12-5

 

AlexH 14-6

 

jaybuck43 11-5

 

SpideyFein 13-6

 

Dark Knight 12-6

 

wipple 12-6

 

ninanina 12-6

 

musicmeta 12-6

 

iceman399 14-7

 

Conan_Aficionado 12-6

 

MetalPSI 13-7

 

AL Comics 11-6

 

Montezuma 11-6

 

jimbo_707 11-6

 

Scturo 11-6

 

Omaha-CGC-Comics 11-6

 

toro 11-6

 

byosti 11-6

 

trmoore54 12-7

 

Unca Scrooge 12-7

 

paradigmcomics 10-6

 

collector_bill 12-8

 

Amazing Spidey 12-8

 

01TheDude 10-7

 

Couchy81 10-7

 

Silver 12-9

 

Red84 8-6

 

comicdonna 8-6

 

WEBHEAD 10-8

 

jessebrook1 8-7

 

spideyfan76 9-8

 

manicnerd 11-10

 

fiberbiskit 7-7

 

Plantman 8-8

 

s-man 8-9

 

Based on my math I'm pretty sure I am 10-8 instead of 8-6

 

Mine is off as well. Can we get a recalculation please.

 

4 bullseye's should garner the extra points, no?

[jaybuck43]

Mine is wrong as well. I should be 15-6

[BlowUpTheMoon]

sckao is looking into it.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

It wouldn't be a grading contest without a little drama.

[jaybuck43]

[sckao]

 

Yep... One sec. The Spreadsheet had to be modified at the last minute to accommodate extra books and the total field formulas weren't updated.

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Yep... One sec. The Spreadsheet had to be modified at the last minute to accommodate extra books and the total field formulas weren't updated.

 

 

 

Ahhh... that makes sense.

[W16227]

Yep - i know I had one loss for sure

 

 

Math is hard

 

 

No worries -

[BlowUpTheMoon]

 

I think the last three books were not added to the win/loss records.

[sckao]

Sorry, I haven't looked at this spreadsheet in about a year even though Blowupthemoon was kind enough to send me some earlier versions which I didn't actually look at...

 

Then I looked at it and realized there were many columns missing...

 

Okay... If you're tied with someone, your rank is really probably tied as well (in terms of SEEDING)

 

DELETED INCORRECT STANDINGS

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Looks like we are going to have 21 first round buys.

[sckao]

I'll still double check the spreadsheet...

 

This doesn't affect the TOP SEEDS who will probably get First Round BYES but it looks like we have 107 players and two brackets of 64.

 

 

[Comicdey]

Almost right. I should be 20-5 as I got three bullseyes if you use all books :-)

 

 

But it probably doesn't make much difference.

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

If you feel good about your grading in the seeding round, donate to the prize thread.

[W16227]

Big props to those running the contest