2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Seeding Round

[Wilson3d]

well...along with my 6 bulls I also got 3 --2s....keeping the universe in check I guess.

[Azkaban]

Totally missed on that Preacher

[BlowUpTheMoon]

when will the rankings be up?

 

sckao is working on it. He will post the match ups later tonight. Maybe even a bracket.

[Wilson3d]

Totally missed on that Preacher

 

 

OMG! Me too! I could only see the small scan and thought it looked WAY better. I'll have to make sure and figure out why I was only seeing the small pics on some of them for the next round.

[SonOfWolF]

Wow I was so confident and I did terribly.

 

[W16227]

One loss

 

Bring it

 

 

 

[Azkaban]

Totally missed on that Preacher

 

 

OMG! Me too! I could only see the small scan and thought it looked WAY better. I'll have to make sure and figure out why I was only seeing the small pics on some of them for the next round.

 

 

If I go with the big pics I'm to harsh on them

[stanley1883]

So I think I missed the cutoff, but if I didn't, 21-9 by my math.

 

So to clarify, if I guessed 8.5 and it was 7.5, that means not within .5 therefore 1 loss correct?

 

Also once we get to the 9's a guess of 9.0 and a grade of 9.4 is still technically within .5 therefore it would constitute 2 wins right? regardless of the fact that it's 2 grades off?

[Wilson3d]

Totally missed on that Preacher

 

 

OMG! Me too! I could only see the small scan and thought it looked WAY better. I'll have to make sure and figure out why I was only seeing the small pics on some of them for the next round.

 

 

If I go with the big pics I'm to harsh on them

 

I know what you mean. I usually look at both but on the higher grade ones I like the Large Scans.

[MetalPSI]

Better than I thought I would do

[Azkaban]

Totally missed on that Preacher

 

 

OMG! Me too! I could only see the small scan and thought it looked WAY better. I'll have to make sure and figure out why I was only seeing the small pics on some of them for the next round.

 

 

If I go with the big pics I'm to harsh on them

 

I know what you mean. I usually look at both but on the higher grade ones I like the Large Scans.

 

Yeah now that I look at the larger scan I see what I missed

[Azkaban]

So I think I missed the cutoff, but if I didn't, 21-9 by my math.

 

So to clarify, if I guessed 8.5 and it was 7.5, that means not within .5 therefore 1 loss correct?

 

Also once we get to the 9's a guess of 9.0 and a grade of 9.4 is still technically within .5 therefore it would constitute 2 wins right? regardless of the fact that it's 2 grades off?

 

no that would mean 1 loss I think

[W16227]

Look at first post - within .5 is 2 wins - a 9.0 guess on a 9.4 book is in (at least I hope so, )

[stanley1883]

I understand if we're 1 grade off, 1.5 grades off, but the .5, not withing .5 has me confused just a little, especially around the 1's and 9's as they don't go by halves

[SpideyFein]

I suck!! Wow. I thought some were pretty tough. Am I the only one?

[BlowUpTheMoon]

A big shout out to the contestant to who had the balls to call a book a 9.9

 

First time that has happened.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

From the first post:

 

Shin's explanation:

 

 

If you are spot on, you will get THREE WINS

If you are within and including .5, you will get TWO WINS

 

If you are .6 to 1.0 OFF, you will get ONE LOSS

If you are over 1.0 OFF, you will get TWO LOSSES

 

People with THREE BULLSEYES get a PLUS ONE WIN

People with FOUR BULLSEYES get a PLUS THREE WINS

 

[kav]

It just seems odd if grade is 9.4 and one guy guessed 9.2 and another 9.0 they both get the same points.

But it seems fair because even CGC is .2 off in resubmitals

[drewincanada]

A very average 18-8. Glad it's the seeding round. I'll pay more attention next time.

[AL Comics]

No more grading from an iPhone for me...