2016 Green Eggs Grading Contest -Round 8

[porcupine48]

i just checked...it looks like slab sqishy marks.shenaniganigans.

[Azkaban]

Now I see it

[thirdgreenham]

puh..puh..pair of 3s?

[Azkaban]

BA 12 how is that an 8.5

 

too low?

 

too high?

 

I had both around 9.0

 

 

I had it at 9.4 forgot I was going to go 9.2 and didn't change it, so too low to me but now I see what I didn't before

[Ron Rau]

BA 12 how is that an 8.5

 

There are long vertical creases along the spine. A read copy that presents really, really well.

 

Wow, 3rd. I have perfect vision and I cannot make out any vertical creases at all. Just had my eyes checked 2 weeks ago. For real.

 

I had it at 9.4.

[IncredibleHauck]

These grades on these books are . I can see the reason for the Crow but that BA 12 is no worse than a 9.2

[aszumilo]

I had them at 9.2 and 8.0 respectively.

[thirdgreenham]

BA 12 how is that an 8.5

 

There are long vertical creases along the spine. A read copy that presents really, really well.

 

Wow, 3rd. I have perfect vision and I cannot make out any vertical creases at all. Just had my eyes checked 2 weeks ago. For real.

 

I had it at 9.4.

 

Get Azkaban to show them to you.

[toro]

BA 12 how is that an 8.5

 

There are long vertical creases along the spine. A read copy that presents really, really well.

 

Really apparent from the back cover scans.

 

I still can't see them.

[Azkaban]

BA 12 how is that an 8.5

 

There are long vertical creases along the spine. A read copy that presents really, really well.

 

Wow, 3rd. I have perfect vision and I cannot make out any vertical creases at all. Just had my eyes checked 2 weeks ago. For real.

 

I had it at 9.4.

 

Get Azkaban to show them to you.

 

 

[GeeksAreMyPeeps]

I had them at 9.2 and 8.0 respectively.

Same! Although I flirted with an 8.5 on the Crow.

[01TheDude]

People who scored 4 points or more generally moved up... Results coming up (slowly).

 

[Azkaban]

to the east side

[thirdgreenham]

These grades on these books are . I can see the reason for the Crow but that BA 12 is no worse than a 9.2

 

So, when you're buying books, buy the book and not the label.

 

***or remember that not all 8.5s are created equal***

 

As we've seen throughout this contest, there have been some really awful 5.0s and some really nice ones.

 

 

[jcjames]

Good lord that is a horrible 8.5 Crow!

 

I THINK i might have stayed above water on this one.

[*Bronze age fan*]

I thought that stuff was those Newton things.

[Azkaban]

These grades on these books are . I can see the reason for the Crow but that BA 12 is no worse than a 9.2

 

So, when you're buying books, buy the book and not the label.

 

***or remember that not all 8.5s are created equal***

 

As we've seen throughout this contest, there have been some really awful 5.0s and some really nice ones.

 

 

always buy the book

[SpideyFein]

I was going to say 9.4, then 9.2 on the BA, then said I've seen BA12's with a lot of wear and said 9.6. What was I thinking?? I have to stop psyching myself out. Of course, take my time too. 9.0 on the Crow!!! Man, another tough one.

[jcjames]

I had them at 9.2 and 8.0 respectively.

 

I gave 9.0 to BA12 abd 7.0 to that crunched Crow cover.

[jhutton2]

One bulls eye and one -1