March Madness Grading Tournament - Round of 64 3 3

[Azkaban]

1 minute ago, manicnerd said:

That DD looks like a 9.2 on the label

I think you're right

[W16227]

[Patriot6]

Yikes, isn't DD missing  corner and Herc is all smudgy?!

[kav]

did anyone else grade the FF as brittle pages?  ps if I had stuck with my small scan grades I would be sitting pretty right now

Edited March 17, 2017 by kav

[Betty-Bates]

15 minutes ago, manicnerd said:

That DD looks like a 9.2 on the label

 

 

and of course "awww carp".

I totally agree!

Edited March 17, 2017 by Betty-Bates
:*

[FineCollector]

Just now, Patriot6 said:

Yikes, isn't DD missing  corner and Herc is all smudgy?!

I thought I saw water on the back of the DD 

[gorgoguy]

Just now, kav said:

did anyone else grade the FF as brittle pages?

No, but I killed it on spine splits and CGC cares much less that OS and me.  

[FineCollector]

Just now, gorgoguy said:

No, but I killed it on spine splits and CGC cares much less that OS and me.  

The bottom staple is detached, right?

[thirdgreenham]

I didn't get a perfect score!!  

[BlowUpTheMoon]

5 minutes ago, manicnerd said:

That DD looks like a 9.2 on the label

Thank you.  Corrected.

[Patriot6]

2 minutes ago, FineCollector said:

I thought I saw water on the back of the DD 

The BC bottom left corner is gone...

[Iceman399]

2 minutes ago, thirdgreenham said:

I didn't get a perfect score!!  

Me too! 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

If you see a score of (-20) the contestant did not submit grades.

 

FOR CGC POST
TheGeneral 37-1  [71]
letsgrumble 12-8  [45]

oakman29 20-7  [40]
old_dano 16-4  [58]

westerberg14 15-6  [10]
spidermanbeyond 17-4  [67]

mccollect 18-8  [78]
Azkaban 19-3  [78]

canickus 32-2  [-20]
Red84 13-10  [60]

Harry Lime 17-6  [19]
revat  [-20]
JWKyle 19-6  [85]

bighairjer 15-6  [37]
tigers comics 19-4  [22]

Plantman 13-6  [51]
thirdgreenham 24-3  [65]

W16227 22-1  [70]
trmoore54 12-8  [9]

Mio 15-5  [68]
HighStakesComics 17-5  [45]

manicnerd 9-10  [57]
jgallo 22-5  [65]

JWKyle 18-6  [-20]
BYE  [-20]

Richard The Man 14-6  [60]
marmat 22-3  [65]

kryptospidey 23-2  [82]
eeb03 15-9  [60]

90sChild 20-7  [60]
LordRahl  [95]
Black_Adam 17-5  [58]

Hado 17-7  [58]
Sludgesicle Man 19-3  [52]

Michelangelo 10-11  [38]
notbrook 18-2  [-20]

Tsp99 26-1  [95]
porky 13-7  [75]

Buscema's Avengers 17-6  [17]
1Cool 24-7  [68]

Shark 15-6  [47]
THB 17-4  [-20]

01TheDude 10-10  [45]
AJD 26-4  [-20]

Betty-Bates 24-2  [95]
WEBHEAD 6-13  [-20]

jhutton2 1-0  [60]
Every Day A Story 20-6  [33]

KryptoMayor 15-6  [52]
RICKSTARR 19-4  [48]

jaybes 15-7  [43]
Sandflea 24-3  [55]

Iceman399 36-2  [65]
kav 15-8  [33]

Grantley Goddard 15-5  [75]
Thanos88 17-5  [70]

grebal 17-7  [60]
Comicdey 17-4  [-20]

Wipple 10-10  [57]
gorgoguy 22-3  [52]

toro 32-3  [95]
Patriots6 15-9  [17]

MustEatBrains 20-7  [27]
DeadOne 17-5  [51]

Unca Scrooge 1-0  [82]
FineCollector 20-4  [2]

AlexH 14-6  [71]
comicquant 21-2  [93]

 

[trmoore54]

Complete melt-down for me...trying to think of an excuse I guess...went 8.0/3.5/4.5/8.0...I guarantee if I submitted that Flash with the stain on the back I would've gotten a 4.5 at best which is what I graded.  Congrats to my opponent...you creamed me...

[BlowUpTheMoon]

We have another tie!  Overtime book coming up!

mccollect 18-8  [78]
Azkaban 19-3  [78]

[kav]

congrats to iceman and may the force be with you!!!

[old_dano]

wooohooo,  made it to the next round !!!

 

[sckao]

Betty-BAtes is going up against Action Comics

WEBHEad was moved to match with MUstEatBrains and DeadOne

Shouldn't affect any results I think...

on a train...

Edited March 17, 2017 by sckao

[gradejunky]

yargghhhh, I missed the sign up for the contest.  I was wondering when this was coming around again.

 

[kav]

1 minute ago, gradejunky said:

yargghhhh, I missed the sign up for the contest.  I was wondering when this was coming around again.

 

don't feel bad-i wish I hadn't entered!