What is a CGC 9.4 Spiderman #1 worth these days?

[metropoliscomics]

Would like to hear collector's opinions.

 

S

[Primetime]

Would like to hear collector's opinions.

 

S

 

Just checked the CGC census, and there are 5 in 9.4, 3 in 9.6, and 1 in 9.8---I think a 9.4 would be at least $70k...

[Korvac Saga]

About $55K

[FourthWorld]

right circumstance....one that has NOT been resubmitted 3 times (and whatever else was done) to get to 9.4...I could see it getting around 100 K

[phoenix215]

*grabs calculator and takes into account time, grading and collectibility*... $10.99 (plus tax)...

 

Would you be willing to take an offer of $10?

[tth2]

$55-65K, depending on how nicely it presented and page quality.

[batman_fan]

70k +

[adamstrange]

right circumstance....one that has NOT been resubmitted 3 times (and whatever else was done) to get to 9.4...I could see it getting around 100 K

 

Metropolis: Note to self. Sell to Fourthworld.

[FourthWorld]

Only if I can work it to a 9.6

[FFB]

My best estimate is $60-65K. Maybe $70K for a perfectly centered copy with white pages, but I think that's pushing the outer limit given how many 9.6s are out there and available for roughly $35-40K more.

[Aman619]

werent the 9.6 sales records at 90-110K all for that maligned Parrino copy?

are there sales records of the other 9.6s? Cant remember the details

[adamstrange]

Only if I can work it to a 9.6

 

[FFB]

werent the 9.6 sales records at 90-110K all for that maligned Parrino copy?

 

Yep, twice on Heritage and once on ebay. This same copy supposedly also sold through ComicLink to some doctor for $150K, but I only heard that through board rumor so I don't know if it's true. All that being the case, maybe you have a point. But then consider the fact that AF#15 in CGC 9.4 (White Mountain) sold for $126K-150K. I have to think that ASM#1 in CGC 9.4 is worth significantly less than AF#15 in the same grade.

 

are there sales records of the other 9.6s? Cant remember the details

 

Not recent public sales.

[tth2]

werent the 9.6 sales records at 90-110K all for that maligned Parrino copy?

 

Yep, twice on Heritage and once on ebay. This same copy supposedly also sold through ComicLink to some doctor for $150K, but I only heard that through board rumor so I don't know if it's true.

It's true, as it was confirmed to me by the owner, the mythical Chocolate Man.

 

All that being the case, maybe you have a point. But then consider the fact that AF#15 in CGC 9.4 (White Mountain) sold for $126K-150K. I have to think that ASM#1 in CGC 9.4 is worth significantly less than AF#15 in the same grade.

True. Therefore my estimate of $55-65K. I think $70K or more would be awfully high considering a 9.6 only barely cracked $100K.

[tth2]

By the way, does anyone else think it's a bit odd that the Guru himself, Steve Fishler, is canvassing the boards for a valuation on ASM #1?

[JLA_ALL_THE_WAY]

Uh, thinly veiled attempt to advertise a copy for sale...?

 

Would he ever do something like that?

 

Maybe he just misplaced his copy of Overtstreet? (Man, this would be the perfect place for a "fist-stroking-air" graemlin.

 

Rick

[Comicdey]

Uh, thinly veiled attempt to advertise a copy for sale...?

 

Would he ever do something like that?

 

Maybe he just misplaced his copy of Overtstreet? (Man, this would be the perfect place for a "fist-stroking-air" graemlin.

 

Rick

 

or maybe he's in the market buying one, and looking to see what the potential upside is these days.....

 

good for him if he's got one on line.

[evilsly]

9.2's seem to be regularly selling at 38k or so, so 60k for a 9.4 is certainly in the ballpark

[batman_fan]

Virtually everything comes down to advertising. Look at the OO thread on the Golden-Age board.