CGC Confusion

[Flee-Marquette]

At an office birthday party held in his honor, CGC grader West Stephan was handed a piece of birthday cake and instinctively began to assess it for a numeric grade.

 

[comicwiz]

At an office birthday party held in his honor, CGC grader West Stephan was handed a piece of birthday cake and instinctively began to assess it for a numeric grade.

 

 

[Mike Bray]

9.4 ( slight trimming to the right edge )

[50 Cent #II (1st)]

Don't forget the chunk missing from the spine and the rat chews...

[Ze-man]

It's obvious the cherry was added to the cake "after" it was made.

 

So the cake is restored.

 

 

Ze-

[OrangeNemesis]

obvious color touch ups...

[Timely]

It's amazing what I find in these centerfolds!

 

West

[deathlok]

10.0 Minty-Fresh

[AnthaiHERO]

i think there may be some artificial coloring keeping it from a gem mint

[comicdonna]

At an office birthday party held in his honor, CGC grader West Stephan was handed a piece of birthday cake and instinctively began to assess it for a numeric grade.

 

Happy Birthday West

[deathlok]

i think there may be some artificial coloring keeping it from a gem mint

 

That comes from the manufacturer, CGC doesn't mark down for that.

[ShoNuff-migration]

 

Hopefully he ate the cake before giving the prostate exam.

 

[joecgcmaniac]

 

Hopefully he ate the cake before giving the prostate exam.

 

That WAS the result of the prostate exam...

[Big Daddy]

At an office birthday party held in his honor, CGC grader West Stephan was handed a piece of birthday cake and instinctively began to assess it for a numeric grade.

 

 

It doesn't look to be Golden Age. More of a Bronze or Copper age time frame.

[Flee-Marquette]

 

Hopefully he ate the cake before giving the prostate exam.

 

That WAS the result of the prostate exam...

[MutantKeys]

[Mac Man]

1.5- This piece has been detached from it's "cover"

[innocuous]

Geez. You guys are at CGC are so cheap, you make him wear the gloves during a cake break. At least have him take them off and put them in a locker. Well, I'm sure he washed them before getting back to grading.

[50 Cent #II (1st)]

Wait, what kind of stain is that in between the layers? Some kind of surprise filling?