Game: SILVER AGE SURVIVOR SERIES - Round 3

[Zonker]

Tough one.

 

FF 2 & Showcase 8 are 2nd appearances.

As is ASM #1.

 

True...true... But there you have the whole #1 dynamic as Mutantkeys notes.

 

I'll stick with TTA.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Screw FF 2

[Guardian Comics]

I'm an FF guy, so I'll leave #2 on the list one more round and take Showcase #8 off. I'd rather own a copy of Showcase #8 though, so I could sell it and buy FF#2 and 3 and a few others. ASM #1, is the 1st issue of the most widely collected at least Silver Age title, if not overall, it sure as heck doesn't deserve to die this soon and is a top 5 book no matter what. It's the same arguement I have heard forever on X-Men #94. You can complete a run of X-Men's without GSX #1, so it is a key to that title, just as ASM #1 fits in a title run more than AF#15 does.

 

Jim

[jmg3637]

Stomp out that little AntMan

 

No way should this classsic book go out now

 

[Aman619]

Tough one.

 

FF 2 & Showcase 8 are 2nd appearances.

GL 1 is a 4th app. Flash 105 is a 5th.

But I'll go with the Ant Man intro, just cause I can't see him as anywhere nearly as important historically as the others.

 

I agree with 1 and 2 above. But not AntMan.

Im going with GL1 as its only a 4th appearance. Lookaline the knives are sharpened for other books in this round, but all 4 listed in your post will soon be gone. Then it will get a bit more interesting.

[ernster]

so long, TTA

[Comicdey]

get the man in tights outta here.

If we were using that criteria, we'd have to vote ALL of the books out (except Hulk 1 and TOS 39, I guess).

 

TOS 39

[toro]

Well I'll cast my vote again for FF #2. But I'm willing to bet that it will still survive! Skrulls vs first Ant Man. I'm not a Big Ant Man fan but come on, give the little guy some love! Toss the cows!

[Lazyboy]

Tough one.

 

FF 2 & Showcase 8 are 2nd appearances.

As is ASM #1.

How about JLA #1? 4th appearance of the team and 1000th of each character.

[piper]

Adventure 247

[1koko]

That was my vote

[Mac Man]

Amazing Fantasy 15 for me

[-cryptkeeper-]

Showcase 8

[goldust40]

It's got to be Green Lantern 1....such a low-key first issue. At least Flash 105 had the Mirror Master on the cover - all we get is a puppet, and no fanfare. Showcase 22's cover was a classic, this isn't.

[JuliusSeizure]

Thanks a lot for doing this, Shadow.

 

I went with Showcase #8 this time. I actually would have added Flash #123 to your list, and ranked it higher than the issues we're voting off now.

[joe_collector]

Showcase 8

 

Bye

 

Okay Marvel fans, join in en masse and get rid of this DC.

 

The total votes for Showcase 8, GL 1 and Adventure 247 are off the chart, so we need to combine votes and not splitting them.

[comic_lot]

 

Oooh, that's really impressive. Size of an ant with human strength. You must be able to clean house on those other ants, huh? Hey! Hey, Hulk! Hey, check this guy out.

[joe_collector]

But we're NOT comparing Showcase 4 to Astonishing 27, are we?

[Fan4Fan]

Screw FF 2

 

All of you FF 2-haters... just you wait, Bendis is bringing the Skrulls back to the prominence they deserve when it will be revealed that everyone in the Marvel U is a Skrull and has been since 1964.

[jmg3637]

If it was not for DC leading the way with Adventure 247 there would be no X-men

 

 

And while we are at it the Doom Patrol begat FF4