We're all different people. I'm sort of a blend of you two. Not being an American, I don't fit into this current great divide of yours. (As a Libertarian, I don't fit anyway.)
Like Rich I prefer funny animal comics to PCH but I also like GGA for obvious reasons. But I'm interested in neither Superman or Batman from the Golden Age. Among DC's, it's Green Lantern, Flash, Black Canary, Hawkman, Doctor Fate, Hourman, Starman and Kirby's Sandman and the Newsboy Legion I really like.
I played all sports with my friends but being skinny and uncoordinated I was never any good and couldn't even make a school team. But now I have no joint pains or knee problems because I never participated in competitive sports. And after lifting some weights after university, I ended up looking like I must have been an athlete! (I'm still no good at anything though.)
Meanwhile I was heavily into the Rolling Stones, Doors, Animals, Kinks, the Cream, the Who and rock music and hi-fi components in general. I grew my hair long to annoy my father, but with my red Dodge Charger I looked not so much like a hippie but like a greaseball hood which is the image I preferred to project. But I was actually a bookish scholarly academic at heart! And I still am. I don't even have a TV!
So yeah, I'm a blend of you and Rich. But like I say, we're all individuals.