-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
-
Posts
1,292 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by Montezuma
-
-
-
-
I'll try and get more later, a lot of this is thanks to the GCD. Let me know if you see any screw ups on my part.
-
How good of a deal is too good of a deal?
Montezuma replied to Westy Steve's topic in Comics General
Leaving aside the little old lady living in rags and dying of starvation who, out of all her possessions managed to keep her NM Action 1 and is now willing to sell it to me for $5. I’ve always lived by the following 1. If the person offers me something at their price, it’s perfectly all right to buy it even if their price is way below FMV. If I sold it for a large profit, I may send them an anonymous donation, but I would not feel obliged to. 2. If someone comes to me with a collection and asks me to estimate what its worth I need to be honest in my estimation and then offer what I’m willing to pay. I also reserve the option of not doing the estimation if I don’t feel it would be worth my time. I used to buy a of collections, and rarely lost any when giving an honest estimate. I once had a lady contact me with 750 Golden Age / 50’s books. Most were in mid-grade and nice. I estimated the collection was worth in the neighborhood of $5,000 (this was around 1982) and told her there was no way I could afford it, but if she’d sell me the high grade Little Lulu run at a fair price I would get her offers from dealers for the rest. She responded that she and her Husband had talked to a couple dealers who told them the collection was worthless and offered them $1 each for some of the books like the one below. She asked me how much I could afford. At the time I had just gotten out of college and was basically broke. I told her I could come up with $500 which was way less than the $1 a book, and she said I could have them for that price. A few years later she called me up when one of her sons wanted to sell his Silver age collection I looked it over, and it had been cherry picked and was mostly subscription copies of DC books; however since I now had money and felt it was appropriate based on first buy, I bought them for considerably more than I would normally have paid As to Grandma and her Action 1, I’d explain to her that the book is only worth $1, but I’d give her the $5 out of generosity, either that or wait until she turned to leave and then mug her. -
-
-
I pick them up whenever I find cheap copies, along with all the Super Comics reprints they're fun to chase.
-
Show us your Bonnetts "Pedigree" Comics!
Montezuma replied to Robot Man's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
-
ufo extraterrestrial related comics
Montezuma replied to misshalos's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
-
Show us the worst "restoration" you've seen
Montezuma replied to SOTIcollector's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
Bought this one years ago, it was cheap due to the amateur resto, The front cover was whitened using "white out" -
-
*** MATT BAKER COVERS ONLY NO DUPLICATES***
Montezuma replied to Joshua33's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
-
Post your Garage Sale/Flea Market/Antique Mall Finds Here
Montezuma replied to Shark's topic in Comics General
The sad thing was there was a box full of DeCarlo Millie's and Irma's, but they were all low grade and every one was missing pages. At a buck a piece I picked out any with decent covers, but most were completely shot. A stack of Dell Peanuts, also all missing the centerfold, -
Post your Garage Sale/Flea Market/Antique Mall Finds Here
Montezuma replied to Shark's topic in Comics General
-
Post your Garage Sale/Flea Market/Antique Mall Finds Here
Montezuma replied to Shark's topic in Comics General
-
Did Tim Holt #30 inspire the Zodiac Killer?
Montezuma replied to Sarg's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
Many moons ago my father bought a Lionel Train and got 400 comics thrown in on the deal, this was one. -
2019 March Madness - Round of 48
Montezuma replied to BlowUpTheMoon's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Thanks, I usually finish about the middle of the pack, so I've got my fingers crossed for this round -
Catholic comics - post ‘em if you got ‘em!
Montezuma replied to jabats's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
Sunday Pix ran weekly and teh Catholic Church published these two, each contained comics, but they we're pretty weak with forgettable art -
Catholic comics - post ‘em if you got ‘em!
Montezuma replied to jabats's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
-
Catholic comics - post ‘em if you got ‘em!
Montezuma replied to jabats's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
A lot of them came out of St Paul, so they show up occasionally around here. Treasure Chest and Topix were the big 2 running hundreds of issues over decades And even some collections of stories from the above -
It's a real nice book in hand,but with the discoloration and store stamp 8.5 was a happy gift
-
Well on this one it looks like I was too tough,I was expecting a 1.8, hoping for 2.0 with the press. It got 2.5 so I was happy
-
Glad to see I wasn't crazy,With the book in hand I was expecting a 6.0 and hoping for a 6.5,it came back 8.5 OW.