Hey Tats,
Sorry to hear about your packaging. I received 4 books, and they were in bags and boards, taped together inside 2 harder pieces of cardboard. To me, his shipping was pretty good.
The 4 books were:
OFF70 7.5 If I were selling this, I'd give it a F- 5.5
OFF 64 7.5 Slightly better than the #70, this is a Fine 6.0
SSWS 97 4.5 Graded fairly well, I'd say-it's a fine 6.0 with a popped upper staple, VG+ 4.5 is the only grade I can agree with
SSWS 154 7.0 With the spine creases, wear at top, chipping at right, and rust migration from one staple on back cover, I'd be giving this one a Fine 6.0
These books didn't appear faded, but I will have a look later today with my overcopies.
Andy