• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

scburdet

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5,427

  • Joined

 Content Type 

Everything posted by scburdet

  1. scburdet
    4.5. I can't see a 5.0 or higher with the reader crease & what looks like a stain to the right of the date stamp. Looks like a water stain on the back cover too.
  2. scburdet
    I think the size of the missing piece would be just over the bar to get a 0.5, but close to a NG. The only reason to grade this would be to make sure it stays in one piece.
  3. scburdet
    7.0/7.5
  4. scburdet
    If it's ink, a dry clean will not remove it. i think people sometimes try magic erasers, but you have to be really careful to avoid a restored tag. IMO, there's enough light edge wear, small spine ticks & less than perfect corners so there's already a 9.0/9.2 ceiling. The top edge could be distributor ink, which wouldn't be treated like ink transfer.
  5. scburdet
    1.8
  6. scburdet
  7. scburdet
    I'm giving this a solid GA bump up to 7.0/7.5. Nice looking one.
  8. scburdet
    that BRBC is a little questionable too. If it was just the tick, I'd say 9.6 was possible. With the BC, I'd say 2 grades lower is likely. He signed mine in pink between Deadpool's arms. Looks awesome. Enjoy the con. I have my facilitator carrying a couple of things down there for me.
  9. scburdet
    9.2/9.4
  10. scburdet
    6.0 The couple of bigger color breaking defects can't be helped
  11. scburdet
    1.0 too
  12. scburdet
    3.0/3.5. Piece out sets the ceiling
  13. scburdet
    Some kind of stain or foxing. Standard cleaning won't remove this, and unlikely harsher methos would work in addition to garnering a purple label. Around 5.5/6.0
  14. scburdet
    7.0/7.5
  15. scburdet
    5.0
  16. scburdet
    6.0/6.5, I think lower.
  17. scburdet
  18. scburdet
    CCS is probably fine for this. I think they're mostly lacking in going the extra mile cleaning/pressing. I believe they do a quick surface clean & smash and go on to grading
  19. scburdet
    3.0/3.5 is the right range for a piece out that size. There have been recent sales for <$50 for copies of this that look to be in better condition, so grading will be a money losing proposition. The only justification to submit this would have to be preservation for sentimental reasons.
  20. scburdet
    There appears to be a long light crease through the bottom BLC, most noticeable around the butt of the gun and plane. 7.0 max
  21. scburdet
    8.0/8.5
  22. scburdet
    8.5/9.0
  23. scburdet
    I would be curious if there is tanning on the inside covers. The little bit of tanning on the back probably caps this around 9.0/9.2, but I've gotten surprised by tanning on the inside covers that was light.
  24. scburdet
    9.2/9.4 You are correct that pressing this one is out.
  25. scburdet
    7.5/8.0. Maybe a little better if it was pressed