Regardless, he's still the most popular, most successful, and dare I say, most important NY sports figure of the last 50 years.
With that said, I understand your point and agree to some extent. And, that's coming from a lifelong Yankees fan. Dave Winfield was my hero and I endured hours of Mantle highlights as my dad reminisced on his childhood.
Mantle was playing 50 years ago. Even Mattingly was a far better player. There's no doubt Jeter is a HoF player, I'll give him that. It's just that his game, while consistent, doesn't warrant the praise he gets. I can name 10 yanks that had more talent, just not as long a career for a variety of reasons. Players I'd pick before god Jeter.
Mattingly (pre-injury)
Mantle- I won't even waste words
Rivera
Munson (pre death)
Reggie
Ruth
Gehrig
Winfield
DiMaggio
Lefty
You felt the need to specify the period of his career you'd consider?
Yes.